The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner
61 - 80 of 145 Posts
Exactly.

Statistical research on the record books has shown that B&C class bucks tend to come more frequently in a developing/expanding deer herd.

From the turn of the 20th century through the early 1900's, almost every stem of the aboriginal forest in Pa had been cut, coupled with the fact that subsistence and market hunting had just about wiped out the deer herd. Throughout the 20's and 30's, the old growth Hemlock/Pine forest gave way to hardwood regeneration and game laws protected the herd, creating perfect conditions for deer to thrive. There were far less people, period, in those days and so there were fewer people hunting. Then, along comes WWII, and there was very little hunting for a few years. All of those factors allowed bucks to eat well and get some age on them. The late 40's through the late 50's were banner years for big bucks in northern Pa. By the 70's, the hardwood forest had matured, and combined with the over protection of does and increased pressure on bucks , that habitat and herd was degraded.

Same situation from the late 60's through the mid 80's in southern Pa. Up until the late 60's, there were very few deer in that region. Then the beginnings of urban sprawl began to create a lot of reverting farm land, perfect deer habitat. Most hunters traveled north to the big woods in those days and there wasn't much pressure on the southern herd. So, once more, you had well fed bucks getting some age on them, and record bucks were being taken. Now, clean farming and ever expanding suburbs are putting an end to the banner days in the southern tier.
Exactly correct!!!

Well stated as well!

I will start a new topic with the time periods and region of the state for the record book bucks prior to 2007. I need to update the more recent years into the data. Maybe later this winter I can do that.

Dick Bodenhorn
 
I measured a buck killed in Allegany county in about 2006. It was a typical 6x6 that had the g3 broken off the right beam. I don't have the scoresheet but I remember that it still netted 172. Would have been in the low 190's if that tine hadn't been broken off.

That buck was taken with a shotgun by an Amish hunter. A minute before he shot him, the buck walked past his brother who had no buck tag. I know of several b&c class bucks killed locally by amish hunters that won't ever be entered in any record book.
 
Firearm Non-Typical:
1) Ed Dodge 1942 = 238-6

i always admired this buck, the mount used to be at the Erie Sports store, maybe it still is. i believe it was remounted. if i remember the story right it was shot in the "Jumbo Woods" SGL near Albion, PA in Erie County.

amazing feat, amazing deer.
 
Is Floyd Reibson related to Duane Reibson (maybe father & son?) who has a farm along Rt. 154 up in Sullivan County,? I know Duane from having draft horses..
 
Save
Is Floyd Reibson related to Duane Reibson (maybe father & son?) who has a farm along Rt. 154 up in Sullivan County,? I know Duane from having draft horses..
I don't know, but you'd certainly think so as the buck was killed out of Hillsgrove.
 
Save
The #3 typical firearm is a picture of Floyd Reibson.
Shot near Hillsgrove, Sullivan County, one of my all time favorite Game News stories.

You are correct. I hunt Hillsgrove. Reibson got another one there that was almost as nice too!
 
Save
Reibson did track his buck in the snow.
There was a picture of him with that buck and another that he had harvested that was just as big.
Not sure what happened to the other rack.
Floyd gave the other one away to friends from NY. It was mounted. The PGC tried to track it down but no luck.
 
Save
Another one of Floyd Reibson with both his bucks. The one on the right is the missing one. The one on the left is a top five PA typical.
 

Attachments

  • Like
Reactions: TBrom
Save
I googled it and this is what came up
 
Save
Discussion starter · #79 ·
I bet this was a traffic stopper on that street? You have to love the old days...a shotgun, Woolrich and hang the buck in a tree in the front yard.

#24 Non-Typical Firearm = Harry Webeck - 1946 Fayette County 193-2
 

Attachments

61 - 80 of 145 Posts
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.