The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

Storm Chasin'

662 views 11 replies 3 participants last post by  Trout Traveler  
#1 ·
I’ve probably posted this same title to a fishing story 10-12 times since joining this site some 25 years ago. The reason being that it’s a reoccurring theme for a trout fisherman this time of year. At least for an aggressive one it is. But such is the life of a late summer trout angler in Pennsylvanian more years than not and this one is absolutely no exception. Despite all of that rain in May and early June the tap has been turned off in a big way and trout fishing, at least mine, has pretty much been ground to a hault do to water conditions and this blasted heat we’ve had all summer. I’ve seen water temps this year that I haven’t ever seen on typically cold streams. Now, maybe that’s because I use a therm more but you catch my drift! It’s been a very hot and now mostly dry summer.

Thankfully there has been SOME rain here and there. At least enough that I’ve only really had to water the garden, berries, and fruit trees a few times while mother nature has handled the rest. Even less occasionally we’ve gotten enough of a splash of water to bring a trout stream here or there up enough to fish for a day. This happened recently. After a long spell of only fishing low water spots we had an evening of welcomed thunderstorms and one in particular trained over a favorite area of mine for a good hour or more. I watched streams rocket up to near flood stage from my couch and watched them drop nearly as fast. It was enough rain to not allow them to drop all the way before the curve on the USGS graph started to break a little less steep and I knew I might have a short window the next day to hit something other than my same ole' same ole' fishing spots which have been utterly exhausted at this point and if I never see them again this year it’ll be too soon. I needed a change of scenery and some mountain views.

I wasn’t in a hurry the next day and in fact I didn’t arrive at the creek until close to 11am. Very unusual for me but I know that even though the creek was flowing at a perfect level at daybreak, that it would still be muddy and needed a little time to clearly. So I waited for it to drop a little more and when I arrived it was indeed a little lower than I would like but flowing with a little color which was good.

Image


What wasn’t good was the water temp. This normally cool mountain stream registered 66, almost 67 on my first cast. I’ll fish to 67 but once I see 68 that’s it. Besides, the fish usually don’t hit well at 67 and at 68 they typically don’t really hit at all. 66 didn’t exactly inspire optimism. But I was there so I was at least going to give it a little run.

Image


Things started out pretty slow. I got a hit from the first run and some some fish follow my spinner from the first pool but nothing was being very aggressive. That’s often the case when water temps are in the upper 60’s. The good news was that it wasn’t long before the first wild brown came to hand and it was in good spirits after being hooked so things were looking up.

Image


As I moved away from the truck and further away from easy access the fishing started to pick up

Image


What started as a ‘well just enjoy your time and catch what you catch’ turned into a ‘I might be on my way’ type of day. ‘On my way' is what I usually mutter to myself when the day has all the markings of a 100+ caught outing.

Image


This particular stream is broken up in the open stretches and posted stretches and none of them are very long. You fish an open stretch for 2 hours and then ride back to the truck and drive up to the next open stretch and so on. It’s a little annoying to have to the fish that way but it’s a great stream so you just do what you have to do.

Image


Stretch #1 yielded 43 trout in 2 hours. The fishing was getting better and better but I eventually came to the dreaded yellow sign over the creek. Back to the truck to section two.

Section #2 is my ole’ reliable stretch. The fishing is always consistent there. It was today as well yielding another 44 trout in 1.5 hours.

Image


To fish the 3rd open stretch I have to ride my bike downstream as there are no safe parking spots. This stretch is hit and miss but today it was a hit. It was nearing 3pm which is much later than I like to typically be out but since I started late I figured I’d stick it out a little longer. Good news was this last stretch was a hit and not a miss today. The water cooled down a degree during the cooler cloudy day and the water level was just great for that stretch. The fish were out pretty good and they were now in a hittin’ mood so I zipped up over 100 for the day and continued on till I absolutely had to high tail it out of there to head for home.

Image


I considered that a bonus day catching an unexpected 117 trout. It was a real delight to be able to fish a ‘normal’ trout stream since it’s been so long. In general this has been yet another very disappointing year for stream levels but I’ve made due where I could. There’s still some significant time for things to change and waters to come back up but it’ll take a near miracle even to bring any meaningful long term change to the creeks in my area. Basically the only think that would help at this stage is tropical moisture with reinforcement rain days later. There is no amount of thunderstorm that can boosts streams for more than a day at this point. It could rain 6” tomorrow night and it would just flood and then be low again 48 hours later. It’s just dry out. At least for this day…this was a welcome change of scenery.
 
#5 ·
Yeah for sure. The August of 2021 was exceptional in the East but we haven't had a good August sense. September for that matter either. At least not in the Eastern portion of the state. This is shaping up to be the worst of them all without change and there's only a week and a half for that so it'll probably go down in the books is the worst August in the last 5 years or so.
 
#6 ·
Last year a tropical storm roared through the central part of the state and caused some flooding. After the waters receded, I fished a few places that I never get to fish in August. It was nice to get to fish those places, but you don't it to occur because of a hurricane.
 
#7 ·
I used to turn off fishing for trout in July and I would come back around October. I would fish some native trout creeks after July, but it was unusual. I usually fished the streams that smallmouth bass inhabit. If I caught a stocked trout (July-Oct), then it was a great day. I think my personal record on smathmouth is about 20" and 5lbs or so. I never weighed it. I should have weighed my bull head catfish. It was 21 1/4" and I guess it weighed 5 -6lbs. I found out years later, that the record was 4lb 10 or 11oz. Oh well, I caught him, measured against my rod and I found out after I got home what length he is. Never weighed him. Never weighed my 27 1/2" native brown trout either. I know he weighed at least 10 - 11lbs.

Back then, I didn't know about water temperature and trout. Back then, I loved to fish and it didn't matter what type of fish I caught. I usually release them, except panfish once in awhile.
 
#8 ·
There are too many anglers who don't carry a stream thermometer. They're not expensive and every angler should carry and use one. Not only for the summer months, but they can also be helpful in any time of the year. In the summer, they're a must have.

In the summer, I take the water temperature before starting to fish. If it's 66, I will take the water temperature every two hours and leave if it hits 68 (65 on brook trout streams, but it's extremely rare for me to fish a native brook trout stream in the summer).

There are some streams that have signs warning anglers about water temperature.

There are quite a few misconceptions about water temperature (misconception in green):

1.) Warm water kills trout. Warm water has less dissolved oxygen that cold water. The lack of dissolved oxygen is what stresses trout and makes them prone to disease. Moving water contains more dissolved oxygen, so trout will often move to riffles when the water gets warm, if they can't find deeper water, spring seeps, or cold water tributaries.

2.) Shade instantly cools the water. I've had anglers tell me that they thought water in short shaded stretches is much cooler, even water that flows under bridges. Unless it's a very long stretch, the water doesn't have time to cool before it flows out of the shaded stretch. If you want proof, take the water temp at the top of a short shaded stretch and at the bottom. There will be little difference, unless there's a spring or cold water trib in between.

3.) You can tell if water is cool enough to fish by feel. How the water feels will be affected by the air temperature and humidity. If you're fishing on an 85 degree day, water that is 72 degrees will feel cool. 72 is too warm to fish for trout.

4.) 70 degrees is the lethal temperature for trout. That used to be the commonly held belief. Brook trout begin to feel stress at 65 degrees, while browns and rainbows begin to stress at 68 degrees. Trout can live in water that is much warmer if it's oxygenated. Trou will still feed, though less at higher water temperatures, but the extra stress of being caught can kill them.

5.) You should not fish for trout during July, August, and early September. Streams that are deeply shaded, have a significant amount of spring influence, or are located below bottom release dams often have cold water, even in the summer. I was berated on this site a year or two ago for fishing in the summer. He assumed that because all the streams in his area were in the mid to upper 70s, that they were throughout the state. It depends on the individual stream. I know of quite a few cold water streams, and as mentioned, use a stream thermometer to make sure they're cool enough.

One more note: sometimes in the summer trout can be seen bunched together where a tributary enters a stream. If you see that, it's a sign that the mainstem is already too warm and the trout are stressed, seeking out cooler water. Those trout should be left alone. If you use a stream thermometer, you will likely not come across that situation, since you'll know to leave the warm water.
 
#12 · (Edited)
I feel I have to correct an erroneous statement I made earlier in this thread. I said a year or two ago that I was berated for fishing in the summer by someone who assumed that because the water temperatures were warm in his area, so they must be warm all over the state. I went back and looked up the post and I wasn't berated, but was merely questioned if I had checked water temperatures because everything in his area was very warm. He also didn't assume that all streams were warm. Now, my post at the time listed the water temperature at the start of the day (60) within the first two paragraphs and I also said that we waded out when the water temperature reached 68 degrees, so the guy obviously missed that. But I wanted to correct the record and also to apologize for my errors.