The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
41 - 60 of 90 Posts
PGC.... the way they word it, sounds like speculation. Read it for yourself in this years digest. My argument is that they "believe", or "can be spread" instead of, are spread, and that's not conclusive, is it ?

Here's another......"eventually leading to death" and then in the 3 paragraphs later....how stupid does this sound??? "more likely? to die annually than uninfected deer" which is it ??? they can't even conclude one way or another ! LOL

And another...."tiny holes to form in the brain" and why not say they test the rest of the meat of an infected deer to show if the prions spread through out the body ???? They just conclude about the brain, and central nervous system. Personally....... I don't think the PGC has qualified people to determine the reason for the epidemic or able to identify the cause.

I don't think it takes a person to be more educated then just reading the write up in the Digest, really I don't.
 
He got kicked out of a university and has no vaccine.
He currently works at the University of New Orleans

Me: How is your progress going?
Bastian: Please refresh my memory re who you are?????
Me: I am just curious how your research is going on Chronic waste disease. Me: I'm just a hunter wondering.
Bastian: All is going well .. Survived the storm IDA.. Thanks for your interest
 
Bet whatever you can afford to lose. I'm old enough to remember that Dr. Salk was held in very high regard for his work in coming up with a real and effective vaccine. The same goes for others throughout history, once their work was confirmed.
 
Bet whatever you can afford to lose. I'm old enough to remember that Dr. Salk was held in very high regard for his work in coming up with a real and effective vaccine. The same goes for others throughout history, once their work was confirmed.
So why the medicine man pic? You’re doubting what someone is legitimately trying to accomplish and comparing them to a conartist. Doesn’t make you look good, DIYASUB
 
So why the medicine man pic? You’re doubting what someone is legitimately trying to accomplish and comparing them to a conartist. Doesn’t make you look good, DIYASUB
I understand that you feel bad about nobody on HPA having any belief in what Eveland is saying. With no proof whatsoever that the claims he makes are valid there's little chance of changing anyone's mind.
 
Some background: USP took PGC to court trying to halt doe season in 2007. IIRC, Commonwealth Court initially granted USP a preliminary injunction, but the case was finally dismissed in Feb. of 2008. The court's decision was announced in the morning, before that day's opening at the Outdoor Show (Now the NRA's GAOS). Heard it on the news and helped spread the word at the show.


During that show, USP had signs up soliciting donations for their court case. When they were informed their case had been dismissed, they kept the signs up and donation jars out.

I obtained depositions from several of USP's leaders relative to the court case. Some of them gave conflicting answers in those depositions, when asked about their membership numbers, for example

Few, if any of their responses under oath, offered any clear evidence as to why they'd filed the law suit. Their reasons mostly had to do with their belief, that PGC was not managing deer numbers to suit USP.

:unsure:

For the past several shows, they've had signs up and jars out, soliciting funds for Bastian's CWD project and touting Bastian's efforts, while denigrating other CWD research projects. Bottom line, there are multiple CWD research efforts going on and none have been able to confirm Bastian's claims.
 
41 - 60 of 90 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.