The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

1 - 20 of 57 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
594 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Do you think people will start getting rid of those model Remingtons because of that report on tv? I think that's the only ones brought up in the report. There are tons of them out there. I don't have either but I do have a 7600.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,541 Posts
I have a Model 700 purchased in 1972, never had any problems wth it and it is a .300 Win mag. You just pay attention to basic gun safety!!!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,126 Posts
Hope they do - I'll take'm
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,643 Posts
Heres one of the best takes I've seen on the issue: From David Petzal, editor of Rifles Magazine:

Petzal, a 54-year shooter, NRA Certified Rifle Instructor, former Army Drill Sergeant, and one the country’s foremost gun authorities, had this to say:

On October 20, CNBC ran a program entitled “Remington Under Fire: A CNBC Investigation.” Claimed to be the result of 10 months’ of investigation by CNBC, it was narrated by a Senior Correspondent named Scott Cohn. The focus of the program was the trigger designed in the late 1940s for the Remington 721 (the predecessor to the 700) by Remington engineer Mike Walker. According to CNBC, the trigger was known to be defective almost from its inception; its design allegedly allows the rifle to be fired without the trigger being pulled. This has resulted, the program claimed, in thousands of complaints caused by accidental firings, as well as injuries and deaths.

Those are the bare bones. As I expected, “Remington Under Fire” was a hatchet job. The verdict is guilty from the get-go. No one from Remington would come on the program, nor would anyone from Cerberus, Remington’s parent company. This is not because they have something to hide, but because they know that if they appear on a program like this they will be made to look like liars or fools or both. If you’d like an example, consult any of the “documentaries” made by the lovely and talented Michael Moore.

Scott Cohn’s program exhibits an unsubtle mix of ignorance of the subject as well as serious journalistic deficiencies. First is the attitude toward guns as a whole. There were references to “safe” guns. Memo to Mr. Cohn: There is no such thing as a safe gun. Guns are inherently dangerous, and unless you handle them with care the results can be tragic. Everyone shown on the program who was killed or wounded by a 700 suffered because either they themselves or someone else pointed a 700 at them.

This is poignantly illustrated by the death of Gus Barber, a Montana boy who was shot by his mother Barbara in 2000. Mrs. Barber was unloading a 700 whose muzzle was pointed at a horse trailer. On the far side of the trailer was her son. The rifle went off; the bullet passed through the trailer; Gus Barber died. This was a terrible tragedy, and I am very sorry for the unbearable pain the Barbers suffered.

Rich Barber, Gus’ father, believes his son was killed because the rifle went off accidentally. In fact, Gus Barber died because a rifle was pointed at him. If the rifle had been pointed in a safe direction, all the Barbers would have gotten was a bad scare.

This kind of tragedy can happen to anyone, with any gun, if he or she ignores the prime directive of safe gun handling, put best by Jeff Cooper:

“Do not cover with the muzzle of a gun anything you do not wish to destroy.”

The CNBC program has a scene showing a Portland, Maine police sniper setting off a 700 by simply tapping the bolt. Incredibly, Mr. Cohn asks no questions at all about the rifle. Any journalist with even a modicum of gun knowledge would have dragged the department’s armorer on camera and asked this one simple question:

“Have you modified the trigger on this rifle?”

There is an interview with a West Coast range officer who states that 700s fire accidentally with such frequency that these incidents are called “Remington moments.” This is yet another example of more journalistic ignorance. If the rifles are so unreliable, why did Cohn not ask the gentlemen why they are allowed on the range?

In the course of the entire program, only one shooter is allowed camera time to say what a great gun the 700 is. One. There are 5 million Model 700s out there. Surely more than one person must like them. Could he possibly have found two people to say nice things?

It is mentioned that Remington has just been awarded a contract to build 3,000 more Model 700 sniper rifles, but that the Marines have had problems with accidental firing. I guess it was too much trouble to have someone explain that the 700 has been in continual service as a sniper rifle for more than 40 years, and that is has served with distinction under some of the most adverse conditions imaginable. Otherwise, why would the U.S. Government be buying 3,000 more? Are the Marines and the Army crazy?

Here’s what I can tell you about the Model 700 with the original, Walker-designed trigger (the new 700 trigger, the X-mark Pro, is a different design).

• I got my first 700, actually a Model 725, in .222, in 1960. There has never been a time since then when I have not owned at least one 700. I’ve never had an accidental firing with any of them, nor have I seen one, and we are talking hundreds of rifles and tens of thousands of rounds over 50 years.

• I’ve seen one 700 that should not have been handled. It was an ADL in 6mm that was made in the late 1960s. Its owner allowed a shooter who supposedly knew how to do so, to work on the trigger. He botched the job.

•And there we come to the crux of the matter. If the original 700 trigger has a fault, it is that it can be fooled with by anyone who has a small screwdriver. The adjustments are delicate, and if you don’t know how (or know enough) to keep sufficient engagement between the sear and the trigger connector, the rifle can slam fire, or fire when it’s dropped, or fire when the safety is flipped off. The same thing happens when you set the trigger pull lower than 3 pounds; it is not designed to function below that level, and there are some fools who love to take it down to 2 or 2 ½.

Right now I have an old 700 with a Walker trigger that has had over 5,000 rounds put through it with never a problem. But give me 5 minutes and a jeweler’s screwdriver and I can make it dangerous.

Enough. I eagerly await Mr. Cohn’s next program. I’m hoping it will be on why the public has so little confidence in news reporting.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
13,401 Posts
I don't need their Documentary to convince me to stay away from Remington bolt rifles. All the internet reports of bolts breaking off and extractor breakage on Remington's bolt guns had convinced me to avoid them. And to top it all off they are Push feed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,352 Posts
And I'll add that Marine Corps sniper rifles are about as much Remington as a Jimmy Johnson car is a Chevy.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33 Posts
Hmmmmm!!! I wonder if Remington advertises in Rifles magazine quoted above. Hmmmmmmmmmm! Bottom line...Remington live up to you slogans regarding safety! Listen to you own engineers and technical people.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,815 Posts
I've got 4 of them now, the oldest close to 50 years old. Best bolt rifle made.

I've asked 4 gunsmith, including one from the Marine sniper group, how many bolt breaks they have seen. seems there were two; both where hit by hammers in and attenpt to disloge a severly stuck case. all 4 smiths though the internet bolt breaking off thing was a laugh.

The Trigger mechanism can be a problem IF improperly 'tuned' or if oil or grease is used on the trigger.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,496 Posts
Reports?

How many here know personally, of any broken bolt handles, broken extractors or ADs caused by defective M700 triggers? Not including shade tree-adjusted triggers, of which there may well many thousands.

Yes, there are some potential problems with the older M700 triggers. Most, if not all of the injuries/deaths, could've been avoided by safe gun handling habits. Which doesn't excuse a bad trigger, but it does place the blame where it primarily belongs: On the idiot handling the firearm.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
13,401 Posts
Harrysigafoo said:
I've got 4 of them now, the oldest close to 50 years old. Best bolt rifle made.

I've asked 4 gunsmith, including one from the Marine sniper group, how many bolt breaks they have seen. seems there were two; both where hit by hammers in and attenpt to disloge a severly stuck case. all 4 smiths though the internet bolt breaking off thing was a laugh.

The Trigger mechanism can be a problem IF improperly 'tuned' or if oil or grease is used on the trigger.

I guesss it is hard to imagine a Remington bolt handle breaking off. I mean they are soldered on.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
13,401 Posts
DennyF said:
Reports?

How many here know personally, of any broken bolt handles, broken extractors or ADs caused by defective M700 triggers? Not including shade tree-adjusted triggers, of which there may well many thousands.

Yes, there are some potential problems with the older M700 triggers. Most, if not all of the injuries/deaths, could've been avoided by safe gun handling habits. Which doesn't excuse a bad trigger, but it does place the blame where it primarily belongs: On the idiot handling the firearm.

If the internet is such an unreliable source of information then why are we all on here?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,643 Posts
DennyF said:
Reports?

How many here know personally, of any broken bolt handles, broken extractors or ADs caused by defective M700 triggers? Not including shade tree-adjusted triggers, of which there may well many thousands.
None that I know of. I have shot dozens of 700's 721, 722's and never encountered an issue nor has anyone I've known over the years that shoot alot more than most could ever dream of!!

The only rifle I've ever seen accidently fire was an older H&R Ultra Rifle that someone monkeyed with the trigger on. It could be tricked to fire whent he safety was switched.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,860 Posts
Being involed in organized benchrest in my family for over 20 years I've gotten to see alot of rifles in action..10'000's to say the least..I have neer seem one single bolt ever break off of a 700 action in all that time. And that's in customs and factory classes. NOT ONE! I own at least a dozen or more of them, some right off the shelf and other completed blueprinted by some of the best gunsmith's on the planet and I'm not selling any worried about the bolt breaking off...I'm not saying it can't happen..but I don't think anyone needs to worry about it all night long or forever for that matter!!!
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
13,401 Posts
The topic of bolt breakage doesn't even come up in other quality brands. You can defend Big Green all you want but where there is smoke there is at least some fire.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
67 Posts
If anyone wants to sell their 700 PM me. I have had one accidently dicharge, but my fault I let it get rusty Gave it a good cleaning all good now. The only other ones I have ever heard of people were monkey with the trigger.
 
1 - 20 of 57 Posts
Top