The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

Never Judge a Trout by the Stream it Swims In

2406 Views 12 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  Pa. Slim
9
With the “warmer” air temps hanging around, I made it a priority to get out Sunday morning. I’ve been on a kick lately to fish new streams or streams that I haven’t spent much time on in the past. I planned on hitting 2 new streams and a stream that I only fished once briefly.

Unfortunately while I was approaching the first stream, which ran through a public park, I noticed that the up and downstream sections were heavily posted, so I knew I would only be able to fish for about a mile before I would have to move on. The stream was only about 12-15 feet wide and about a foot deep in most places. The action was almost non-existent for the first 25 minutes until this little brown was fooled.



The action picked up from there, but I was rusty on the hook sets and failed to bring a number of trout to hand. I did manage to hook and bring to hand a nice 14-15” wild brown, but it spit the hook and darted off while I was trying to get my camera out.

Here’s another typical brown from the first stream.



After about an hour and fifteen minutes I hit the dreaded posted signs and began the walk back to my car. On the way out I stumbled across this deer skull. The remaining antler was heavily chewed on.



I moved onto the second stream, which was a bit wider and deeper than the first. At this point the rain was coming down pretty good and it made seeing the bottom tricky. After about a half hour of sloshing around in the stream without a hit, I moved on to a third stream that I had fished once before.

When I arrived at the third stream, it looked low and clear. The stream is only about 10-12 feet wide and about 10 inches deep in most places, but has some nice plunge pools. The action was good from the get-go, but again, I was having trouble setting the hook. About 10 minutes in, I hit a nice hole with an undercut bank and this nice wild brown came charging out and I made sure that I set the hook this time.



After a couple of pictures and a smooth release, I decided to throw one more under the bank and this stockie came ripping out. Kind of surprised me as the stream is not stocked, but it’s amazing where stockies end up.



The very next cast to the same spot and I had a nice rainbow on the line for about 5 seconds before he spit the hook. After that brief fight, the hole was pretty trashed and I moved on.

As I waded upstream, I continued to pick off a good number of wild browns. What amazed me was the size of some of these browns based on the stream that they came from. I would never have thought such a small stream could produce a decent number of big wild trout.







As I was taking pictures of this nice looking stockie, I heard a loud thump right next to me and looked up to see a deer running off that had jumped over the bank.



A few seconds later and 2 of his buddies decided to do the same landing about 4 feet from me. It definitely got my heart beating. As I could see the posted signs coming up, I called it a day.

With the streams as low and clear as they were, the rain showers definitely helped me today. I don’t know how many more trips I have in me for 2012, but if the weather stays like this, I’ll definitely have to sneak out another day or two.
See less See more
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
I'm just curious how can you tell the difference between stocked and wild? Is it because of the coloring?
mattyg123 said:
I'm just curious how can you tell the difference between stocked and wild? Is it because of the coloring?
It's not a perfect science, but color and the spot patterns are what I go by. Some also think that wild browns will also contain orange / red on the adipose fin.

The first picture of the stockie brown was easy for me to identify as one of his front fins was completely worn off fr his days at the hatchery.
Very well done. If this weather continues like that I just might get out. Winter outings are RARE for me but hunting in the warmth isn't that much fun to me. It's been years since I went out from Dec-Feb. It would be nice to do once. It's cool to not have to worry about pressure and stuff.
Trout 2003 said:
If this weather continues like that I just might get out. Winter outings are RARE for me but hunting in the warmth isn't that much fun to me. It's been years since I went out from Dec-Feb.
That would be great if you do get out. I always enjoy your write-ups / pictures and its been awhile since you posted.
nice
I have went out twice since i last posted but for whatever reason neither outing inspired me to write. I can't complain though as I would consider the trout season I had to have reached the 'EPIC' level this year. The past 2 summers have been the most fun I've ever had.
Nice fish
2
Great pics and story, thanks for sharing!!!!
See less See more
what kind of spinner were you using? looks like a mepps or cp swing. nice pictures.
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Top