The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

41 - 60 of 60 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
20,410 Posts
I'd like to believe it, but there are too many suspicious things about it. Did he really think he could fool the entire deer hunting world by faking this? I don't know the man, so I cant say if he's honest or intelligent, but I have to wonder why, if there was anything fake about this, that he would have even had it measured and why, if it was real, did he not pursue official recognition until he had it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,688 Posts
Wow, you had to reopen this can of worms.. I remember when this buck came out into the public through multiple magazines.( no internet back then..lol).. this was declared new world record and 3 officials measured it up and then it was mentioned it needed to be
X-Ray’d and it suddenly disappeared off the face of the earth. Totally not legit..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
I read and studied the information and claims made on both sides of this issue and after extensive research I have come to the conclusion that I wasn't there so I couldn't say either way with any degree of accuracy, just like everyone else who weighed in on this. Thank God deer hunting wasn't banned over this, I would have been pissed. lol
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,248 Posts
...Wouldn't have the buck x-rayed when offered $10,000 to do it...
I became mildly obsessed with case a while back and read a lot on it. This right here is the detail that put me over the edge of calling shenanigans on the deer. Mitch, in one quote about his publicizing the deer, said something to the effect of "it's all about the money." Then, when offered an easy payday to simply have the skull X-rayed, he refused.

He's clearly hiding something and that buck is a fake.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,962 Posts
I became mildly obsessed with case a while back and read a lot on it. This right here is the detail that put me over the edge of calling shenanigans on the deer. Mitch, in one quote about his publicizing the deer, said something to the effect of "it's all about the money." Then, when offered an easy payday to simply have the skull X-rayed, he refused.

He's clearly hiding something and that buck is a fake.

What I find "mysterious" is not just the fact that Mitch isn't talking, but that NOBODY is talking. The well known, official scorers that saw, examined and scored this buck, the people who actually saw the buck just after the recovery, including a GW... all quiet. The fact that nothing has "leaked" out in all these years is amazing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20,859 Posts
So why even comment? Just move on if you do not have a comment.
I guess because the constant quest for horn porn and the general commercialization of deer hunting has in my opinion,diminished the sport.Just the mere fact that one hunter had to threaten another hunter with legal action because his deer was actually bigger than his is enough to say,enough is enough.I try to keep drama at bay in my life as much as I can and to worry about who killed the biggest buck isn't noteworthy to me.I saw dozens and dozens of huge bucks killed in Pa this year that will never be in a record book,a magazine cover or in a lawsuit.That to me is what hunting should be about.As far as the discussion goes,Ole Mitch seemed to be a real fruitcake who liked to look up women's skirts and kill big bucks.Good for him but I ain't interested in sitting down with him and talking about either subject.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,248 Posts
What I find "mysterious" is not just the fact that Mitch isn't talking, but that NOBODY is talking. The well known, official scorers that saw, examined and scored this buck, the people who actually saw the buck just after the recovery, including a GW... all quiet. The fact that nothing has "leaked" out in all these years is amazing.
It is strange and, by all right, sudden. Then again, what Danesdad said could definitely be a major factor.

Maybe Hanson has some really good lawyers.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
609 Posts
I have no Idea if this was real or not but what is interesting to me is the folks that saw this deer after it was harvested did several interviews and they seemed to think their was nothing wrong with it
And if you have the #1 deer as already mentioned why do you need a lawyer your deer is #1 till its not
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,125 Posts
Iirc, it was more about $ than who had the bigger buck.

Having the #1 buck is a financial windfall, and Hanson and a bussiness partner were marketing his buck as the #1 in the world. Rompala jumped in, saying his was bigger, the real #1, and it hurt the hanson bucks value and marketability. Hanson and his partner basically told rompala to put up or shut up, get it x rayed, officially measured and certified as the world record, or quit calling it the world record cus it was hurting their bussiness. Rompala had to make a legal choice and he chose to quit calling his buck #1 and basically went into hiding.

Not sure why you'd do that if things were copacetic, after you'd already sought out the attention by putting yourself and your deer out there, it's not like he was forced to. But when push came to shove, he backed down.

To me, all that scoring stuff is just numbers on paper. You were happy with a deer or you shouldn't have shot him, those numbers really don't mean jack to me. BUT, if those numbers presented me with a bussiness opportunity after the fact, I'd take advantage of it with no second thoughts or excuses to anybody.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,244 Posts
Iirc, it was more about $ than who had the bigger buck.

Having the #1 buck is a financial windfall, and Hanson and a bussiness partner were marketing his buck as the #1 in the world. Rompala jumped in, saying his was bigger, the real #1, and it hurt the hanson bucks value and marketability. Hanson and his partner basically told rompala to put up or shut up, get it x rayed, officially measured and certified as the world record, or quit calling it the world record cus it was hurting their bussiness. Rompala had to make a legal choice and he chose to quit calling his buck #1 and basically went into hiding.

Not sure why you'd do that if things were copacetic, after you'd already sought out the attention by putting yourself and your deer out there, it's not like he was forced to. But when push came to shove, he backed down.

To me, all that scoring stuff is just numbers on paper. You were happy with a deer or you shouldn't have shot him, those numbers really don't mean jack to me. BUT, if those numbers presented me with a bussiness opportunity after the fact, I'd take advantage of it with no second thoughts or excuses to anybody.
Let's face it if you shoot the new World Record, with endorsements and other stuff you are probably looking at a million dollar windfall. Nothing to sneeze at. No corona virus pun intended. >:)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,125 Posts
From what I read, hanson himself didn't know or care about "marketing" that buck. But he was approached by others who were in the outdoor business and he basically let them do the marketing and he was more of a silent partner, aside from a few shows where he was paid to attend. No idea how much he made, but I'll bet it wasn't as much as most folks think.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
609 Posts
One thing many have said about this deer was the way the ears are flopped down some have said that doesnt happen when a deer dies well I just noticed this
and thats not a big muley so no I didnt fake the antlers lol
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,674 Posts
From what I read, hanson himself didn't know or care about "marketing" that buck. But he was approached by others who were in the outdoor business and he basically let them do the marketing and he was more of a silent partner, aside from a few shows where he was paid to attend. No idea how much he made, but I'll bet it wasn't as much as most folks think.
Yep...always the Don King types that pocket most of the money!!!:smile_big:
 
41 - 60 of 60 Posts
Top