Start with the Wayne National Forest. Its pretty big and you can do a lot of walking around there. The Wayne does get hit pretty hard through out the year but there are a few pockets that hold a decent number and good bucks. Your best bet would be to hunt the edges of public and private. Also, there are a bunch of smaller parcels that can be found on the ODNR website. Talk to someone at the ODNR in Athens Ohio and they will point you in the right direction.
Wayne NF is nowhere near Wheeling. Egypt Valley is close and big 14,000+ acres but get pounded hard. Be tuff hunting, lots of guys driving and some very thick area's. I sent you a PM of a much smaller tract of state ground that doesn't get near the pressure.
Where you at in PA? I have an unused salt fork permit that I drew(odds are like 1:100) but its archery only. If youre interested and wanna come get it Ill sign it over too you. No way I am going to have time to get back out there this year.
Its good for you and a guest. The majority of it is now open. When I was out there for my hunt only a very small section was open so I didnt bother.