The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

1 - 13 of 13 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,575 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
This is by no means a mechanical broadhead bash thread because I used rage original 2 blades and hypos with 100% success. I was just involved in a facebook thread about mechanical versus fixed blade.

It is incredible to me the number of people who actually think a bow sighted in with field points and a mechanical head that shoots in the same spot is considered to be "TUNED."

They literally cannot be reasoned with. The #1 and #2 replies are: i have 10 dead deer to show how my bow is tuned properly or my arrow doesn't plane like it does with fixed blades.

For example the last time I shot mechanical heads they were spot on with my field points but so were my 100 grain slick tricks, 100 grain thunderheads and 100 grain ramcats.

The reply I received was: enjoy your fixed blades.

I can understand these folks staying with what has worked but the whole issue was that killing deer doesn't mean your bow is properly tuned. there is just so much more to a properly tuned bow. i have watched field pointed arrows leave the bow very poorly and hit their mark due to moving sights and mechanical heads perform the same. people refuse to understand everything they are leaving on the table.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
487 Posts
Unless they are asking for help.....why would you care how someone else's bow is tuned or not ??
If they don't want or think they need help, move on. Why get frustrated over it ????????
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
19,611 Posts
Be it hunting advice, construction practices or where's the best place to get a cold beer I offer the best correct information I have from years of doing it or first hand knowledge. If they can benefit from what I tell them fine, if not then they can learn the hard way, like most of us.
Its nothing personal and not worth getting upset or thinking about.
Good Luck
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,307 Posts
I agree, I would consider it to be sighted in and if fixed blades were used it would still be hitting the same IMO.
I`ve shot both and have had success with both. At 20-35 yds I don`t think it matters what head you shoot, it you hit that sweet spot.
You shoot the broadhead that you feel you have the most confidence in. There are so many to choose from, it all comes down to making that one shot count when the time comes....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,575 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
im not really upset but people were asking why? i answered them that there bow really isn't tuned properly or as well as it could be and then all these mechanical shooters started at me about how the whole purpose of them is that they require zero tuning and this and that. i remained civil and was trying to explain to them that a mechanical hitting where a field point does, doesn't equate to a tuned bow. they all proceeded to tell me i was wrong. i was just trying to help. once i realize i was talking to the wall i moved along. just amazed by the stubbornness to refuse learning something.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,033 Posts
After a quick stint in retail, I realized there are 4 types of shooters: 1) "the Pie Platers". As long it can hit a pie plate at 40 yards, their bow, equipment, and their ability is tuned for the season, even when they just got it out the week before. 2)the "Low Ball Wanna-Be's". They want the best results with some of the worst combinations of equipment and techniques 3) the "Point Buyers" These are guys that will spend any amount of money to get the "best latest and greatest" because they saw someone else using it. Forget the fact that some people can just shoot better than them or anyone else in the business. 4) the "Swappers"- these are the guys that will change out equipment without learning how the prior equipment performs. They are especially fond of swapping out releases, arrows, tips, weight, stabilizers, rests and sights. They can easily be grouped in with the Point Buyers for the amount of money they spend.

Most have one thing in common. They do not know the intricate balance between a properly tuned bow and properly suited equipment. They have yet to evolve into "archers".

As others have said, you will learn when to just smile and walk away, or in this case, not click on the "reply to this thread" link.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,575 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
you are right guru. i know when to smile and walk away but really thought i could help someone. maybe i did help someone that didn't respond. not one person though was even willing to consider what i was saying. all i had left at the end was a "wow!" hahaha
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,347 Posts
muskyman62 said:
you are right guru. i know when to smile and walk away but really thought i could help someone. maybe i did help someone that didn't respond. not one person though was even willing to consider what i was saying. all i had left at the end was a "wow!" hahaha
Your head and heart were in the right place. Like the ole saying goes..."you can control what comes out of YOU ....but....you can't control what comes back".
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,100 Posts
Helping people can be a double edge sword. Some will listen & learn something. Some will just do what they have been doing. I don't get upset, if people ask I offer advise. what they do with it is up to them.

Befor archery opened, my daughter & I were shooting at the practice range & some one was sighting in their crossbow. We ask if we could check our broadhead arrows as we can only use certain targets for that. He said ok , but your fixed blade arrow won't group like the groups you were getting with FP's. I asked why not. He said fixed blades won't fly like FP's. I said really. he watched us shoot & couldn't believe they hit dots out to 40 yards. I told him if your bow is tuned it will. We had a long discussion on tuning. What he does with it is up to him.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,558 Posts
The tuning process can be a real pain in the butt and I think alot of people just give up after a while and turn to crossbows thinking that will eliminate their problems? You should still strive to find the combo of bolt and head design that works best. I have hunted with people that couldn't hit a 10 ring with their compounds if their life depended on it and missed or wounded several deer every year. After switching to crossbows they have been able to lessen the errors which makes the rest of us happy!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,007 Posts
I understand your frustration Musky. I've come to the conclusion that what you view as a simple, common sense concept just totally eludes some folks. It's not their fault, just how they are wired.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,575 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
fall gobbler said:
I understand your frustration Musky. I've come to the conclusion that what you view as a simple, common sense concept just totally eludes some folks. It's not their fault, just how they are wired.
i absolutely feel that is the case in many instances. i have talked with people twice my age that have been hunting with a bow since they were 12 that really have no idea what they are doing either. i never really mean to insult people but once people believe that sighting in a broadhead only is the correct way, you are going to struggle to tell them differently. lol
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,007 Posts
It's kind of like my wife. She's somewhat mechanically inclined (for a girl :)) and she likes when I show her how things work on her car when I'm working on it. One day she crawled under the car with me and I explained how her front suspension worked and how and why things wear out and even fail. Of course I then had to explain how "good" driving habits can greatly increase the longevity of these suspension components making the car safer and more fun to drive and costing her less money. She seemed to take it all in and understand. Within a week she was back to hitting every pot hole and RR track at 50 mph. All I could do is wince, lol.
 
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Top