The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,729 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
Since things aren't too busy on the boards right now I thought this might be a good time to ask : Have you ever experienced a catastrophic bow failure ? In 41 years of hunting I've had two (well one was on the range).

In the 90's I had a Mountaineer bow. Nice bow, machined aluminum riser. In its third season of use , while on the practice range, the riser broke in half while at half draw. A loud noise and I was standing there with the top half of my bow dangling at my feet. This happened so fast I initially didn't realize what had happened. Upon close examination of the riser I could see a small pock mark on each section of riser. When the riser halves were matched together the pock marks formed a bubble. This bubble must have formed when the original aluminum stock was formed. That riser was an accident waiting to happen since the day it was machined. Mountaineer replaced the riser, no charge.

Fast forward a few years. I was in my first Lone Wolf climber for the very first hunting trip using that stand. Had my one year old Hoyt Havotech. A doe was standing at 15 yards. I drew and settled the pin in the sweet spot just behind the shoulder. Release, loud noise, see the arrow hit the deer in the neck, deer runs 15 yards and drops and dies. As I look down at my bow I notice the bow is unstrung and the cam is bent. I also see a nick on the tree stand where the cam had barely nicked the tree stand. I was lucky to hit that deer with such a lethal hit. Luckier yet I didn't wound it.
That one cost me about $100.00. Lesson here: always be aware of where your bow is in relation to your tree stand (or anything else that could interfere).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,277 Posts
Twice.

First time it was a Pearson hunter classic. Steel cables with teardrop that you hooked the loops of the string to. About halfway thru a 600 round the top teardrop came off the cable as I was drawing, cut my wrist and gave me a big welt across my face, lucky I didn't loose an eye.

Second time was oct 28 of '16. I always draw my bow with my fingers before I leave the house or truck just to make sure everything's ok. That afternoon I did that, but for some unknown reason I decided that my peep wasn't aligned so i let it rotate a little by letting the string roll down my fingers just a little..BANG! What makes a guy do something that stoopid?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,729 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Yeah, i remember those tear drops and some of the ridiculously complicated cables the old bows had. I'm glad you weren't hurt too bad. I thought the same thing about losing an eye when my riser broke.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,277 Posts
That bow was new enough that it didn't have all those extra pulleys and wheels, but old enough that it did still use metal cables. Got it in '86 iirc, but it only went to 66# so i didn't use it to hunt with much, thought of it as a girls bow. Shot it indoors and with fingers i shot mid 590's with it. Used to take it to a meat shoot where they gave hams, steaks, roasts, ect, for the winner each round. Kids ate pretty good that winter till they changed the rules and you could only win 2 rounds per night.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
I fortunately haven’t had one myself but I’ve witnessed two. A buddy was shooting his Mathews Helium when it had a cam failure. Upon release the bow basically exploded in his hand. It was forceful enough to shoot half of the cam over his house into his front yard.
The second was last winter at an indoor range. Guy was holding at full draw with his new Bowtech bow. The top limb cracked apart, what a sound that was inside. Sounded like a .22 shot going off.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,053 Posts
1990, target shooting in the backyard, new Martin Lynx compound, pulled back and heard a crack, bow sounded like a 22 going off, limb split where the flite wheels and axle attached, was a problem for Martin back then on the Lynx. Had a bloody nose and lip and cables wrapped around my neck. After it was over, the neighbor came over and handed me one of the ball bearings that the limbs pivot on, that had ended up on his porch about 20 yards away. Martin replaced the whole bow at no cost. I always think of the consequences had it happened in a treestand.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,729 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
1990, target shooting in the backyard, new Martin Lynx compound, pulled back and heard a crack, bow sounded like a 22 going off, limb split where the flite wheels and axle attached, was a problem for Martin back then on the Lynx. Had a bloody nose and lip and cables wrapped around my neck. After it was over, the neighbor came over and handed me one of the ball bearings that the limbs pivot on, that had ended up on his porch about 20 yards away. Martin replaced the whole bow at no cost. I always think of the consequences had it happened in a treestand.
Well it seems we can all agree that when a bow flies apart the noise it makes is akin to a .22 shot.

If that would have been in a tree stand in 1990, I bet there is a good chance you wouldn't have been wearing a fall restraint. If you were it's a good chance it would have been a belt and not a harness. I know I didn't start wearing a harness until the late 90's. I feel naked in the woods without one now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,590 Posts
No bad failures yet. I did nick the heck out of the bottom cam, trying to shoot an eight point walking around under me. I think I was still using my TSS climber back then. The noise scared me more then the damage to the bow. I missed the deer too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,908 Posts
I changed the modules on my son's Elite Impulse and took it out of the press and laid it down on my work bench. A few minutes later I picked it up and pulled it back and it sounded like it exploded. As soon as it happened I realized my stupid mistake, I never put the limb stops back on the cams. Nothing I couldn't fix in the press, but like I told my son i'm glad I didn't do that to my bow.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,561 Posts
While working in the local bow shop several years ago I had just put new string and cables on a customers bow, one identical to the one I owned. Pulled it back to check timing and a new cable let loose! Top limb came down and the idler wheel hit me and broke a finger! We managed to find all the parts and get it put back together!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,074 Posts
My old Darton Maverick, best bow I ever owned... cam hit the bar on my climber and derailed the string scaring me to death. That doe lived to see another day. New Strings and Cables made it all better.... my pride was a little dinged though!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,755 Posts
I only had one (1) and I didn't see it.
Bow exploded while on its bow holder at home.
Never heard it.
Went downstairs one day and there she was all laid out, limbs straight and strings all torn up.
Limbs were cracked.
Luckily it was an older High Country bow I used as a back up and not my Mathews.


I saw a guy dry fire a bow at Forksville one year, I think his arrow slipped off the string.
Sounded like a shotgun going off.
Worst part was his peep got him in the eye somehow and that was ugly.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
57 Posts
I had a string break on a Martin lynx in the 90s. Got extremely lucky that my bow had no damage and I had a scratch next to my left eye. Scared the heck out of me...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,824 Posts
Had a PSE Mach II back in the day, limb delaminated. PSE replaced the limbs, I gave it to a buddy and those limbs eventually delaminated as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
697 Posts
Watched my buddy's BowTech explode when he came to full draw target shooting in my yard. After seeing that and the fact that BowTech took 7 weeks to get it back to him, you couldn't give me one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,575 Posts
I changed the modules on my son's Elite Impulse and took it out of the press and laid it down on my work bench. A few minutes later I picked it up and pulled it back and it sounded like it exploded. As soon as it happened I realized my stupid mistake, I never put the limb stops back on the cams. Nothing I couldn't fix in the press, but like I told my son i'm glad I didn't do that to my bow.


:grin2::grin2::grin2::grin2::grin2::grin2:
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
12,652 Posts
In the 90's saw a brand new Hoyt raiser break on the first shot. The shooter was the owner of a local archery shop and Hoyt dealer. He wasn't hurt, but he was highly embarrassed.

I once accidentally cut some of the strands on my bow string by carelessly handling an arrow with a sharp broad head while in my tree stand in a great buck location. Ended my first day of an out of state hunt. I had to find a local bow shop and influence the shop to do the work for me that day.

Now when I hunt away from home I carry the last bow string with all the attachments in place plus a portable bow press. I have never had to use it, but I believe it would be the quickest way to get back on target.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,100 Posts
The worst I ever saw, was a lady at a 3d shoot. At full draw the limb bolt broke. The limb wrapped around her arm & hit her square in the face. Broke her nose & blackened both eyes.
The arrow went straight back & stuck in a tree. Strangest thing I ever saw, thank God no one was behind her.
Saw some guys dry fire during winter leagues & at the range. Some were not very good for the bow but no one hurt.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,074 Posts
Since things aren't too busy on the boards right now I thought this might be a good time to ask : Have you ever experienced a catastrophic bow failure ? In 41 years of hunting I've had two (well one was on the range).

In the 90's I had a Mountaineer bow. Nice bow, machined aluminum riser. In its third season of use , while on the practice range, the riser broke in half while at half draw. A loud noise and I was standing there with the top half of my bow dangling at my feet. This happened so fast I initially didn't realize what had happened. Upon close examination of the riser I could see a small pock mark on each section of riser. When the riser halves were matched together the pock marks formed a bubble. This bubble must have formed when the original aluminum stock was formed. That riser was an accident waiting to happen since the day it was machined. Mountaineer replaced the riser, no charge.

Fast forward a few years. I was in my first Lone Wolf climber for the very first hunting trip using that stand. Had my one year old Hoyt Havotech. A doe was standing at 15 yards. I drew and settled the pin in the sweet spot just behind the shoulder. Release, loud noise, see the arrow hit the deer in the neck, deer runs 15 yards and drops and dies. As I look down at my bow I notice the bow is unstrung and the cam is bent. I also see a nick on the tree stand where the cam had barely nicked the tree stand. I was lucky to hit that deer with such a lethal hit. Luckier yet I didn't wound it.
That one cost me about $100.00. Lesson here: always be aware of where your bow is in relation to your tree stand (or anything else that could interfere).

I am with you on the second one. Shot at a doe, and bam.... cable jumped the cam.
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top