On September 18th, 2011, I sat down with a man, formerly of the Amish Mafia. He was a tall man with rugged features. His hands were heavily calloused and he spoken in a firm, yet understated polite manner.
Ummmm, shouldn’t you be in a disguise?
What do you mean? I used to wear a big hat, sunglasses, and a beard. Shaving off the beard, losing the hat and shades, this is my disguise. Nobody is going to recognize me.
I see. How did you get started in the Amish Mafia?
I was working on a farm in upstate New York for Brother Hezekia. I didn’t know it when I started, but he was running numbers for the Amish Mafia at all of the county fairs - horse pulls, pie baking, largest pumpkin, and other competitions. I began to help and did so well, that in the first year I was given my own racket. I was put in charge of the northern New York butter churning. It wasn’t much, but I knew if I proved myself there, there would be bigger opportunities down the road. Eventually I worked my way up and was controlling all barn-raising for New York, Vermont, and Delaware. If you want to have a barn-raising in either of those states, you needed labor, you had to come through me. Those Mennonites were constantly trying to muscle in on our turf and we had to keep them in check.
What else was your family involved in?
We controlled a lot of the flow of trade goods: Quilting and related crafts, woodworking, protection. Drugs.
Drugs!?
Yes Sir.
I am shocked! How did that work out?
Well, I got greedy and I think that was my downfall. Had I kept it small and dealt just the light stuff, I would have been all right. But the money was good. Pretty soon I was into dealing the hard stuff.
Hard stuff? Do you mean Coke?
Coke? Yes, and Pepsi too. Some of our people really took to the caffeine.
I was talking about Cocaine. Where you dealing cocaine?
The what now? Not sure what that is. No, I got into the hard stuff, ibuprofen, nyquill, motrin, and extra strength Tylenol. Had I just stuck with the tums, Rolaids, Asprin, and caffeinated beverages I wouldn’t have attracted so much attention. I was out of control.
Oh. It’s not allowed in your community?
No. That is why we had to smuggle it in.
You mentioned you offered protection, what did you mean by that?
If you wanted to make sure your fruit and vegetables did not get smashed at the farmers market, that kind of thing.
How wide spread is the Mafia within the Amish culture?
Most of us, in one way or another.
How dangerous is the Amish Mafia?
Typically we controlled through intimidation. If you came home and the wicks were gone on all of your lanterns or the strings on the family loom were cut - that kind of thing, it generally got the message across that we were serious.
Do you currently fear for your life?
Nope. I moved to the other side of the interstate. They can’t cross interstate highways in their horse-drawn buggies. Occasionally, I will trip up and blow my cover. I was at a restaurant the other day and I wanted it a bit darker. I walked up and tried to blow out a light bulb. Ooops! Not a candle. Nobody noticed, but it’s those kinds of things that can really blow your cover.
I am very surprised to even find out there is such thing as the Amish Mafia. How long has it existed?
Long time. Even before we were known as the Amish. We used to be with the Mennonites, but we broke off in the late 1700’s. They were getting too liberal and modern for us. When they began using hand pumps instead of a rope and bucket to get their water, we said enough of this new fangled technology and we began plotting to separate. We called ourselves ‘the Fundamentalists’ and we needed income to support our seperationist views. We eventually had enough wealth to purchase some land and start our own settlements and we did. The ‘income source’ just seemed too easy to abandon at that point.
We settled in Las Vegas when it was just a railroad stop. We set up shop there, pre dating the more famous Italian mob by a couple of decades. Vegas has been the center of the Amish Mafia for many years. When the mob got big and noticeable, the feds ran them out. Apparently they are too afraid to tangle with the Amish Mafia. They just let us be.
Were you involved in the casinos?
The what now?
Were you involved in the gambling at the casinos?
No. We handle barn raisings, looming supplies, quilts, and candle making throughout Vegas.
I’m curious. How many barns get raised in the Las Vegas each year?
You mean Las Vegas proper, or the Southern Nevada area. Las Vegas handles all of Southern Nevada and parts of Utah and Arizona.
Yes, the entire region. How many barns each year?
Well, none. Business has not been good the last few decades.
You eventually left the organization and turned on your own. How difficult was that?
It was tough. It was my whole life. But I didn’t like the direction the family was headed. Our new leadership was getting too ‘Hollywood’. Brother Ezekiel, head of the family, had three brand new chrome buggies! Now, why would you need one chrome buggy, let alone three? I finally said enough is enough.