What has everyone had success with - both for holding arrows and putting up with the weather of being outside for a few seasons. I always bought the cheap ones, but feel like I always got what I paid for
I haven't been near a 3D target or range in years.
Trouble I saw with the use of 3D targets was the "target" was in one spot, increasing wear and cost.
Another problem I saw was archery sources replace whole new targets. It doesn't specialize in repairing targets.
I've been making individual non 3D targets for some 20 years. I don't get the supplies from an archery shop. I get them from an industrial store and adapt the material to archery use.
Not enough archers with a construction background. Guess there aren't many with a construction background who knows industrial repair sources.
Target storage over the winter can be a problem. I have all McKenzies in my yard. What I do is disconnect the back from the front, but leave them both on their rebar. Put 1 large (55gal) garbage bag over each section. Make sure they are black bags- the problem is not so much cold, rain, or snow, the problem is UV deterioration. As far as 3D target repair of replacement, the new ones have all gone to a replaceable vitals section so your replacement costs are greatly reduced.