Wife and I spent back to back anniversaries (early Feb) at the Gateway Cabins when we were pre-kids , we really enjoyed the nice fireplaces and setting amongst the hillside with hemlocks and rhodys and being able to go up to the lodge for dinner or a drink.
Also stayed a year at the Calrion River lodge..in one of the guestrooms, it was very nice but we prefer the own cabin thing much more.
The correct answer may depend on what you are heading up for...romantic getaway, family winter vacation, sledding/skiing, guys weekend???
"Only takes a second to change your season" Dad, 1980