Our homeboy Mike Mussina was good. really good but to me he falls just below the great level. I think they gave him credit for playing on a poor team for many years. Sort of the same with Holladay but I think Holladay was great and played too many years on a weak team. The big market teams get the votes. The teams that win championships get the votes. I think if Mussina or Holladay stayed with one team and had no rings they would not be in the hall.
I even think E Martinez is a reach. As much as I hate the Yankees I thing Rivera has earned his place in the hall with the GOATs Waugh!
AR is only a pacifier.You will never grow if it's not in your genes.