i went with muskingum country outfitters http://ohiowhitetailoutfitter.com/ 2 years ago on a shotgun hunt. seen tons of deer and missed about a 140 class the 3 day. doug runs a small hunt with only 2-4 in camp. Food and cabin was good. tree stand are safe. doug does everything to put you on deer. i'm going with dave lusk from southern ohio outfitters this fall on a bowhunt, i could not pass up deal $1300.00 or i would have gone with doug again.
I have gone with TripleB Outfittersof Ohio the past three years, archery. I have harvested two bucks over 140, Ken runs a great operation and the deer are second to none. http://www.tripleboutfittersofohio.com
http://www.whitetailoutfittersofohio.com - Some real giants here. I went with them last year. More people in camp than the claim which based on reviews I've read was about par for the course. The lodge is very nice, the stands are nice, and you'll see more deer than you ever have in your life. Expensive though, I got to go for $1,000 off last year which is the only reason I went.