In my opinion, rinehart makes the best targets out there. Their deer target is just about as good as it gets. As for a little less expensive, the Mckenzie Challenger deer target is pretty good, but the replaceable section is smaller.
Privately, I depended on homemade targets, and pretended what the 1" sticker dots were. And some targets are meant to be aimed at in one particular place. Which I avoided buying like a plague. My cheapness won out in the end. Just can't help it.