Hopefully!!! My 6.5 Swede may finally have a future for a crack at a PA Elk ...if ever drawn!! I have voiced my support to the PGC so many times & appears finally appears they agree!!!!!!!
6.5 MM CREEDMOOR COULD BECOME LEGAL ROUND FOR ELK
The Pennsylvania Board of Game Commissioners today gave preliminary approval to a measure that would permit the state’s elk hunters to use the 6.5 mm Creedmoor round and related .26 caliber firearms.
Existing regulations require elk hunters to use firearms that are .27 caliber or more, with bullets of at least 130 grains. But after a review, the Game Commission has determined that increasingly popular firearms in the .26 caliber range provide adequate and commonly accepted kinetic energies to efficiently and ethically harvest elk.
The change would allow use of .26 caliber firearms with bullets of 120 grains or more for elk hunting.
The measure will be brought back to the July meeting for a final vote.
The "Needmore"...oh....that's "Creedmore" would be fine. OTOH, my hand loaded 6.5x55 Swede will push a 140gr. bullet 2,900fps. Faster and flatter than the Needmore can.
Good for you 6.5 guys. I know many have been asking for this. Although I don’t really understand why. But then again I a 30-06 165gr for deer, 1 1/8oz 3dram for trap, guy so I lean towards bigger is better.
You 6.5 guys should just be thanking the Creedmoor for making your bore diameter relevant. The components have gotten a whole lot better because if it.
Anyone serious about anything in the 264 bores already knew/knows how to shop intelligently for components and have a good supply on hand. If anything, the Creedmoor made bullets a bit shorter in supply because of increased demand.
I have a Swede and a 264WM and there’s been good hunting bullets (since that’s the context here, hunting) available for years in that bore. And available.
The guys who want to buy a box of 50 the day they need them probably got frustrated, but they weren’t suited to own a less common bore diameter anyway.
When I buy bullets of any kind, I buy several hundred.
Primers... several thousand.
Powder, multi-pound containers so you can actually use the same lot of powder for a time.
The Creedmoor coming on the scene hasn’t changed the landscape much for me from that perspective.
But I guess if that’s what it took to get 264’s legal for elk, ok. I won’t argue that.
Just shows a lack of understanding of cartridges and exterior ballistics if it truly was the creedmoor that was the impetus for the change in PA elk. But a win is a win I guess....
I have a 6,5X55 CZ 550FS and shoot Norma USA American PH Ammunition 156 Grain Oryx ammo. Norma loads their PH ammo line hotter than any American manufacturer to 2559 fps for this 156 grain bonded bullet w/gilding metal jacket & lead core. I'm confident this round is capable of taking a PA Elk with no problem. In Scandinavian countries it's a common 6.5 round for moose.
What is legal to use and what is best suited for the task are 2 different things! I know people that hunt deer with .222s and .22-250s also. Legal, yes, best suited for the job, NO!
A lot of people like the 6.5 Swede. They like to use their Walkers or their Canes to rest their Swedes for a steady shot. The only trouble for them is a lot of Retirement homes now don't let them keep their guns. Us younger guys tend to like the Creedmoor better.
Who you callin old?? Been reloading 6.5 Swede for awhile but still young at heart. Of course, mine is a military rifle so not hitting the numbers I'm seeing here.
you're gonna make your trigger finger weary with all your pot stirring... lol
I have a 264WM that I love to death. It's just a cool round, even though from a truly functional standpoint, there's not a whole lot it does that a well-crafted 270 Winchester load can't.
As for the Creedmoor, a buddy of mine is a retired Marine Raider/MARSOC guy. He's all in on the Creedmoor, and he's one of the most talented reloaders I know in addition to his ninja experiences. And he's been to the middle east more times than I'm sure I'm aware, and he's pulled a lot of triggers in situations most of us can't even imagine. So if he says the Creedmoor has some merit, I'll buy it.
BUT....
The Creedmoor's "liability" if you want to call it that is the rabid fanboy presence on the 'net that is comprised of guys who do the round no favors. A buddy of mine in a facebook reloading group tagged me in a conversation where a 6.5CM fan was trying to explain how the BC "Creedmoor bullets" was superior to the bullets used in the 260 Remington.
Um.....say what?
I think the round suffers from its fan base, not from its relative merits.
And I still think it's laughable that no one thought any other 264-bore worthy of elk until the CM and it's lower case capacity came along...lol. But, I'll take the change, whatever the impetus for it. I question the 120gr threshold for the bullets....if that's ok, then 257's are too. But...whatever. I get it. A line has to be drawn and it has to be somewhere.
6.5 Creedmoor is nothing but a glorified 260 Remington. A lot of hype IMO. For elk in a 6.5 bore I would choose either a 264 Win. Mag. or better yet a 6.5/300 Weatherby Mag. Those two are for sure elk cartridges.
When 6.5 guys choose to denigrate the Creedmoor they forget that it is a fact the vast majority of shooters are not reloaders. The 6.5 Creedmoor gives the factory ammo purchaser outstanding options at reasonable prices.
None of the other 6.5's do that. Of course the Creedmoor is the success.
That's why I advised my buddy not to get one. He doesn't reload and says "The Creedmore is all over. Can get a box wherever I go." Yep, for now. Not saying it's going away or anything like that, but who knows in 10 years? There were a lot of WSM, WSSM, RUM etc available at Walmart before too. He's a guy that buys a box when he needs it.
Wait until the 6.5 PCR (Precision Rifle Cartridge) gets real popular, the under power 6.5 CM and 6.5 x 55 will fade in the blue yonder.
The next new thing is here and already there is a 300 PRC to go with the 6.5 PRC.>
Trigger Creep, my Dad's cousin used a .22-250 for years and I saw what happens when you have a less than perfect hit! Friend of my Dad's used a .222 but only took neck shots on standing deer. Didn't say they won't ever kill a deer just they are not the best suited.
The 22-250 may make a mess of deer but it will absolutely flatten them in their tracks. If I was told I had no choice but to drop a deer right in it's tracks then give me a 22-250 or a 220 Swift.
Double lung a deer with a 6.5x55 Swede or a 6.5 CM with a 120 gr. Sierra Pro Hunter bullet and see what happens. First time I shot a big doe with my 6.5 CM it went down so fast I thought I missed and the deer ran off with the other deer that were standing around there.
The above buck was a large deer(for PA) and shot through both lungs with a Norma 156 Grain Oryx. It stood motionless for about 5 seconds then legs collapsed. Same here....thought I missed. I have also killed quite a few deer with the Hornady 140 grain Superformance ammo(Interlocks)....same type of results. Since bear runs concurrent with part of deer season...I opted to shoot the Norma 156 grain Oryx ammo. If ever drawn for Elk....it would be my fodder. Lots of reloading possibilities but I don't shoot enuff anymore plus the factory ammo I'm shooting would be difficult to beat. The Creedmoor does offer a better selection of hotter loads vs the Swede but I only need one.:smile2:
I wonder if I could find that 156 gr. Norma Oryx bullet to load in my Creedmoor hhmm some possibilities there. That would work well on a bear too. Ya got the gears turning in my head haha.:grin2:
Had a 6.5 Swede that I liked a great deal. Just too many guns in the closet and thinned them out. There has been few if any new cartridges in the past 40 years that were actually new and not just revamped old work horse cartridges. Taking the name Creedmore is a bit presumptuous.
The only reason Swede load data is so mild is because of Norwegian Krags and Swedish M96 actions (not as strong as a 98 Mauser)
Run the swede in a modern bolt gun and it can be run like a modern round too.
And then it looks a bit different.
It gives up very little to the 270 then.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community
2.8M posts
46.8K members
Since 2004
A forum community dedicated to Pennsylvania’s hunters and enthusiasts Come join the discussion about trails, licenses, fishing, game laws, styles, reviews, optics, accessories, classifieds, and more!