Originally Posted by trapper233
Will the CR's with the 285 pound breakaway J-hooks reliably hold them?
I was muzzleloading with a friend, one evening two years ago, a few hundred yards from a cable setup. Near quitting time, I heard a coyote barking in the vicinity of that cable restraint. When I met up with my buddy, I told him I want to check on it. Upon investigation, I confirmed a catch. But the coyote broke out of the restraint at the 285# J-hook. He wasn't in long due to the lack of disturbance in vegetation. I found ALOT of long grizzled neck hairs to confirm.
I would think it doesn't matter if it's 285# in "S" or "J" variety. It should hold. Perhaps it was a defective J-hook. But in 2007, on a forum I'm sure I'm not allowed to mention here, Newt Sterling stated this:
"When I heard that PA. was looking into legalizing Cable Restraints. I was AGAINST it from the "get go".
Some guys thought I was against PA. getting snaring legalized.
Why would they think that ? I make part of my living building and selling snares and snare supplies.
I was pushing for them NOT to settle for something that dont work. But to hold out for something that does.
What you guy's got in PA.Was a bad regulation(no pun intended)Now you have a bad regulation with changes.
More simply put. Snares work. Cable Restraints DONT"
His belief was/is 75%, or less, catch & hold capability is the best one can expect out of cable restraints. I read on the same site, that some state uses a 125# BAD on a kill pole for coyotes. Kills the coyote, but the deer can still get out. I'm sure we go with CR's because of close proximity to pets and hunting dogs.
Out of experience, be careful going to the maximum load PA allows. (Which is 390# off the top of my head). Someone please correct me if I'm wrong. Avoid deer trails as that load will hold younger or lighter weight deer. And then make sure your anchor is in FROZEN or SOLID ground. That's the only way the BAD will work.