2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt - The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community
LinkBack Thread Tools
post #1 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 05:29 PM Thread Starter
The Man
loridr's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Pa, Dauphin co
Posts: 6,917
Back To Top
2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

I spent the week of October 11th through the 16th 2015 hunting at Deerfield Plantation. It was a six day hunt so it’s a long story with lots of pics.

I’ve been doing an annual hunt in South Carolina at Deerfield Plantation for 20 years now, my first hunt there occurring in 1995. Joining me this year were Joe (HPA Bumblehick), George (HPA Muttleysgone), Joe’s cousin John from Phila., as well as Jim and Bill from Perry County Pa. We usually go the third week of October so as to have the best chance at heavy rut activity; the rut usually falling mid-October on the coastal plain of SC. We backed the hunt up a week this year so that George could do the hunt.

Last year, I included a lot of background info and pictures of the lodge, property and hunt specific rules so I’ll not do that this year, but those who may be interested in that information may click the link below for last year’s post:


Anticipation of this year’s hunt was somewhat dampened by an unprecedented 18” of rainfall received in the area a week prior to our hunt, with St. George smack dab in the worst of it. As things turned out, the main property at Deerfield was relatively unaffected other than a small percentage of the more than 300 stands being rendered inaccessible; it’s really amazing how rapidly water can come and go in that deep sandy soil down there, it’s like a sponge. My favorite lease however, The Creek (Brown and Down), was closed to hunting for the majority of the week by the State due to severe flooding along the Edisto River. DNR finally lifted the ban on Thursday of our hunt and we were fortunate to get one afternoon in hunting the lease with good result as you shall see.

We had a full house most of the week; with all of the regular second week of October hunters being joined by us third week yahoos, and a few corporate hunters drifting in and out, we had from 15 to 18 hunters in the woods on any one sit through Thursday morning. George, John and I were guided by Harry, Hugh Walters cousin and a long time Deerfield guide and character. We were joined in the truck by 80 year old Bill Sr. and his two sons Walt and Bill Jr., originally from New Jersey. It was a great group and there was no end to the cutting up on each other and guide Harry; I think I used up my allotment of laughter for the next few months . Joe was in Hughs truck.

The weather was perfect, sunny and slightly cool all week, but the actual hunting was very strange, definitely pre-rut hunting. Even with so many hunters in the woods we were seeing very few deer, but the younger bucks were walking and we managed to put together a slow pick of bucks, killing one or two on just about every sitting. As best as I can recollect, all but two hunters killed at least one deer during the week. As is always the case at Deerfield, at least one hunter absolutely catches fire and this week it would be Bill Sr.

On The Hunt

Sunday morning, October 11th.

We were hunting the 1000 acre Trophy Area and I drew a stand on a woods road in an overgrown cutover. Other than the road, I really couldn’t see anything and that’s just what I saw… nothing, not a squirrel, not a bird, nothing. The good news was that we were on a backwards rotation and would be changing areas in the afternoon. Several hunters had action though: a young 14 year old hunter killed his first deer, a spike buck, and Bill Jr. hit a very good buck that was harassing some does. The shot was at the moving buck however and after Harry’s tracking dog Chucky jumped the buck several times it was apparent that we’d not catch up to that one. I was unable to get a pic of the young hunter and his buck as it had already been cleaned by the time we got in.

Sunday evening, October 11th.

We changed locations and were hunting the Horse Farm, one of the 4 points total areas. I was in a tower box deep in the hardwoods and could see a long stretch of road in either direction. Harry had told me that hunters had been seeing a decent buck crossing the road about 100 yards to my right but that he never seemed to pause and nobody had been able to get a shot at him.

Views from the stand

I hadn’t seen anything, when just at last shooting light, I had a big deer step out within 30 yards of the stand on my left, but it got me as I turned my head , looking right into my eyes and had me totally pinned down. We did a Texas standoff for a few seconds and it didn’t really spook, it just walked off of the road. As far as I know it was a big doe. We did have some luck that evening; Joe killed a nice 6 point and Bill Sr. a 4 point; Walt saw 4 deer but had no shot opportunity and George saw a button head.

Joe with 6 point

Bill Sr. with 4 point

Monday morning, October 12th.

Back on the same stands as the previous evening, I had better luck. At first light I looked up the road to my right as a deer stepped out onto the road. It was still too dark to make out if it was a buck or doe with the naked eye, but I wasn’t concerned about that anyway as I’m always going to kill the first deer I have a chance at when hunting at Deerfield. Never really looking at the deer’s head, my crosshairs found its shoulder. At the shot, I completely lost the animal in the muzzle flash. It was 7:05am. Not having seen the reaction of the deer I decided to give it plenty of time before checking on it and settled in for the wait. In the meantime, a flock of turkeys made an appearance.


At 8:30am I decided to go check on my deer. Finding lots of lung and rib shards on the road and a good blood trail leading into the woods, I began to follow the blood trail, but after only 15 yards or so the deer had gotten itself into some “crawl on yer knees” crap and I elected to back out and wait for Harry. Once he arrived we quickly found the deer about 15 yards past where I had stopped trailing. It was a large bodied, heavy but small racked 8 point… I was elated. That morning others had some luck as well, good and bad. Bill Sr. missed a doe, John knocked down a small buck but we never found any blood, and the cousin of the young fellow mentioned previously killed a good 8 point buck. Once again, I did not get a picture of the kid and his buck as it was processed by the time we got in.

Loridr’s Buck

Monday evening, October 12th.

We changed areas and stands and were hunting the main property, 4 points on one side. I was in a 20 ft. lean-up on a woods road and had another slow sit, but was treated once again to a flock of turkeys and got a picture of a Barred Owl that perched quite near my stand. Bill Jr. killed a small 7 point, John a 7 as well and a very nice one at that, and Bill from Perry County killed a doe.

Barred Owl

Bill and John with 7 points

Tuesday morning, October 13th.

Found us back on the same stands with a similar result for me; all I saw was an armadillo. George passed on a small 4 point. Bill Sr. was catching fire though; he killed a big doe at about 7:30am, then, at about 8:30am here comes a big buck walking directly towards him right in the road. He let it come on and dumped it, a big bodied, heavy horned 8 point. The tracks in the road told a story: the buck had come up the road from a long ways away on the downwind side of the stand and more than likely had picked up the scent of Bills doe lying in the road. Jim from Perry County also hit a big buck that morning but the dog just kept jumping it up and they couldn’t catch up to it. It appeared to be only a shoulder hit.

Bill Sr. with his big buck

Tuesday evening, October 13th.

We were in the Trophy Area once more. I was on a very nice stand on a small food plot at a V in the road back in the woods but saw nothing. Walt saw and passed on a spike and a fawn, Joe hit and lost a hog. Once again Bill Sr. could do no wrong, seeing and passing on a buck that was close, but not quite, good enough to make the trophy restriction (8 point, 14” inside spread). He said had he not had to pay for killing a second deer that morning, he definitely would have killed it and paid the fee.

Wednesday morning, October 14th.

Same stands. Our crew saw no deer but George thought he saw a big hog cross before first good light. Joe (Bumblehick) had a great morning, killing a very good 10 point and a spike.

Joe’s bucks

Wednesday evening, October 14th.

We hunted one of the 4 point total leases along the powerline. I was back in the woods on a large food plot, more of a field. At 4:30pm someone across the hard road decided it would be a great evening to open up with the AR’s and AK’s and for next hour George and I were treated to a never ending barrage until about 5:30pm. Then, to add insult to injury, whenever a train would go by on the main line a pack of coyotes would open up within a few hundred yards of our positions, this being repeated 3 times until near dark. Needless to say, we saw no game that evening. It was a big night for the group as a whole though: Bill Sr. killed a big, broken up 8 point; Eric and Wally from Massachusetts killed a big 8 and a 5 point respectively. Wally also killed a doe, as did Jim from Perry County.

From left to right: Wally, Bill Sr., Eric, Jim

Thursday morning, October 15th.

Back on the same stands. I saw a big gobbler, Bill Sr. killed a doe, John missed a doe and Joe saw two small bucks but either had no shot or passed them up, I can’t remember.

As mentioned earlier, the Creek Lease (Brown and Down) had been closed to hunting by DNR since the flood, but was to be reopened after midnight on Wednesday. Hugh and the guides had gone in on Wednesday afternoon and found they could access only eight of the dozens of stands they have on the lease, but they went ahead and corned those. At the conclusion of the Thursday morning hunt, most of the hunters had finished their respective hunts and pulled out, leaving only six of us in camp, and Hugh asked us if we’d like to hunt The Creek. We all jumped at the chance.

Thursday evening, October 15th.

On The Creek, Brown and Down (no antler restrictions, no fee for button bucks). At 3:40pm I had settled into a tripod stand in a beautiful spot nestled in a grove of large oak trees in an old cutover with the road going through mature hardwoods to my left. At approx. 3:50pm, here comes a doe walking toward me from my right and I poleaxed her right in the road when she stopped at the corn. I went over and pulled her off of the road and into some shade.

I had no sooner climbed back in the stand when a big doe crossed the road near where I had shot the first one. She disappeared but I got ready as I figured she was looking for the other one, and sure enough, at 4:05pm I saw her in the brush about to step back onto the road. I had clear shoulder in the scope so I dumped her right there, and went over to drag her to the shade and the first doe. Having incurred a second deer charge, I resolved only to take another one if it was a good buck. I saw a big doe at about 6pm, a little spike at 7pm and another deer on the corn at dark. It had sounded to me as though everyone had shot at least once.

From the stand

Sure enough, everyone had killed. I got the two does; John, Joe and Jim (from Florida) each killed a doe; Maurrie from Graterford Pa killed a 6 point; and George killed a doe, a spike and a very good 8 point. We were fortunate to have had the opportunity as that will be it for The Creek for a while. If anybody goes, everyone must go, and with more hunters starting Friday morning and only eight stands available, it may be several weeks until the lease can be brought back into the normal rotation.

The group with our deer

George with his nice buck

Friday morning, October 16th.

Our last day to hunt, we were back on Trophy. I was in a tower box on a small food plot back in the hardwoods, with a 60 yard view down the road to my right and what would turn out to be a very nice view down into the swamp to my left. At first light I saw a buck with a good rack step out in the road, and, unconcerned with the requirement (they don’t get mad, they just get paid), I dumped it DRT, right in the road. It was a very nice 8 point and I couldn’t have been happier. It was a good morning; John killed a spike buck, and Joe and Jim (from Fla) each killed doe.

My last day buck

Friday evening, October 16th.

Same stand, last sit of the hunt. I’d seen two big gobblers earlier in the swamp. At 7pm a big doe came out and walked diagonally through the food plot. I thought about taking her but she was acting peculiar so I held off in the case a buck may be following. No such luck. Right at last light a deer stepped out and hit the corn in the plot, but it was too late to identify what it was with certainty so I passed. It definitely did not have a rack on it.

To sum it up:

It was a strange and often frustrating week of hunting but in the end quite successful. We had a full house most of the week and everyone was a pleasure to be around; most being regulars for years. The camp as a whole had an impressive take of 17 antlered bucks, one adult buck with completely broken off horns, and a dozen or so does. As for our little crew, I took two bucks and two does; Joe took three bucks and a doe; George took two bucks and a doe; John took two bucks and a doe; and the Perry County boys, Jim and Bill, each took a doe.

The weather was to get much cooler down there this week and I’d suspect those hunting now may be having a fantastic hunt. Having said that, one of our own HPA’ers, Milbry18, has a crew of 5 down there as I write this and I can’t wait to hear how they did upon his return. Next season I have a conflict with a moose hunt and won’t be hunting Deerfield until December. I’m excited about it though, as some of you may remember I had a heck of a Deerfield hunt in December of 2012.

Good Huntin’
loridr is online now  
Sponsored Links
post #2 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 05:34 PM
Diehard Outdoorsman
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Washington PA
Posts: 4,887
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Awesome write up.

The United States of America has the greatest people on earth.
Deer archer is offline  
post #3 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 05:45 PM
Hooked on HuntingPa
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Central PA
Posts: 334
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Sounds like a great trip, thanks for sharing.

Are you really old enough to remember when there were huntable numbers of deer on public land?
KingB_44 is offline  
Sponsored Links
post #4 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 09:01 PM
Diehard Outdoorsman
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Berks, McKean
Posts: 3,293
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Look forward to this post every year. Great write up and thanks for sharing.
5chunter is online now  
post #5 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 09:06 PM
Regular Member
Run2Catch's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: 1A, 1B, 2G & NY 9-J
Posts: 2,017
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

I read and enjoy your Deerfield hunts every year. Way to go.

Lake Effect Beagles
V.P. Presque Isle Beagle club
Run2Catch is offline  
post #6 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 09:46 PM
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Hagerstown, MD
Posts: 19,190
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Great writeup Loridr!

I have to thank you for that initial invite to Deerfield way back in what, 2007?

This was my 4th trip back w/Loridr and it was a blast. If I was a millionaire I'd buy a corporate membership for myself and hunt down there all the time, it really is a special place.

The owner Hugh is great, the guides are great, the hunting is great. Just like any other place you can have quiet days w/o lots of activity, but you don't get bored, it's totally different than PA or MD where I spend most of my hunting time. You realize that when you have tree frogs and lizards crawling around you in your stand.

Great trip. I'll definitely be going back. These trips mean more to me each year. With 2 little kids, all the extracurriculars and other responsibilities, traveling all the time for work, it's more difficult each year to hunt like I used to (all the time). Getting down there for 5 days w/o any interruptions and just hunting- you can't put a price on that!


When was the last time you heard somebody say "Go ahead, it's a free country"?
Bumblehick is offline  
post #7 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 10:00 PM Thread Starter
The Man
loridr's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Pa, Dauphin co
Posts: 6,917
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Originally Posted by Bumblehick
Just like any other place you can have quiet days w/o lots of activity, but you don't get bored... You realize that when you have tree frogs and lizards crawling around you in your stand.
That reminds me: I've been trying to get a good pic of those Geicos for years but the little buggers won't tolerate it. Too busy hustling insurance I guess.


loridr is online now  
post #8 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 10:33 PM
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Hagerstown, MD
Posts: 19,190
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

I did not want to appear all high and mighty down there correcting the legions of good old boys who correct people who refer to them as chameleons, telling them they are geckos. They are actually Anoles ( Link ) .


When was the last time you heard somebody say "Go ahead, it's a free country"?
Bumblehick is offline  
post #9 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 11:31 PM
Senior Member
cspot's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Western PA-2A
Posts: 11,971
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Congrats Loridr!!! Always look forward to this post!!

Traditions only last if you pass them down to your kids!
cspot is offline  
post #10 of 24 (permalink) Old 10-21-2015, 11:31 PM
The Man
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Mercer County, PA
Posts: 7,160
Back To Top
Re: 2015 Deerfield Plantation Hunt

Great report Loridr! Looks like an excellent trip.

“did you get all that on camera sport?”
eddie spaghetti is offline  

Quick Reply

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the The HuntingPA.com Outdoor Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page

Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome