After many recommendations for the Husky X-ACT contour's I finally broke down and put them in my F350. From what I gathered they were a better fit over the weathertechs for my particular vehicle. I haven't been disappointed. The mats clean easily and make vacuuming out the carpet a 5 minute job. I'd buy the husky's again and wouldn't even think twice.
You probably can't go wrong with either. Both with beat the generic one mat for all vehicle ones. I put Husky X-ACT's in my Tacoma last summer. Just cleaned them for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. I thought for sure they were going to be stained. They took a beating this winter but I just sprayed them off with the hose and they look practically brand new. No scrubbing at all.
I've had both. I like the Husky's better. They have groves in them which help catch the dirt, thus my dress shoes aren't always covered in dirt that is sliding around on the flat surface of the weather tech.