I had a 90 Toyota pick up, when they made only one size, and it had no name. It was a great truck, loved it.
Traded it in on on a 2000 Dakota Quad Cab. No major problems, but the quality was not there, it was an OK truck.
Traded that in on an '08 Tundra. Put 180,000 on it. Great truck, still ran great. Still not convinced I did the right thing by trading it in on an '17 Tundra this past November. I really like it. I am getting 17 and expect to get 19 when the weather warms up, as I did with my '08.
I really like the Tundra. I call it my redneck Cadillac.
My advice would be to get a base Tundra Double Cab. The prices are close as is the gas mileage. The full size truck is a must for me at this point.
As far as the other brands, I would not consider any of them personally due to my will earned bias of having had two Toyota trucks, zero problems after a combined 320,000 miles which included a fair amount of towing about 4000 pounds of boat from PA to NY.