Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community

Bear and Elk Hunting Forum



Page 25 of 40 < 1 2 ... 23 24 25 26 27 ... 39 40 >
Topic Options
#3127650 - Wed Sep 25 2013 09:26 PM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
croz2173 Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Tue Nov 06 2012
Posts: 458
Loc: ANF
I've got it!!! Lets keep the governors tag going, but next year make it a mountain lion tag! Valid for the entire license year of course, shooting from the vehicle, spotlighting, and baiting would be legal. We could bring in ten times the money!

Top
#3127689 - Wed Sep 25 2013 09:58 PM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
Buckshot1822 Offline
Honored

Registered: Mon Oct 18 2004
Posts: 5117
Loc: Clearfield County (2g)
What I have learned from this thread......

1. People are jealous because this guy has enough money to spend 40k on a tag

2. Most of these people are upset simply because they have never drawn a tag, and someone well to do can just buy one....

3. People seriously over estimate the sport of hunting Elk in PA



The thing that gets me is this: There are worse "poachers" in pretty much every town in Pa, than this guy, and people aren't all up in arms (at least not to this effect) about those guys out hunting deer, etc..........

I don't care what anyone tells you, most of these elk are pretty tame, there are some exceptions, but most of them are relatively tame, and aren't really afraid of people.......I spend more time in the elk range, and around the elk than probably 95% of the people on here.........

This thread is just full of people who are really upset that, this guy can go and buy a tag for 40k, when they have been applying for 10+ years or whatever it is..........most of the people are using the "poaching" thing as a farce to attack the guy.........

PS......I couldn't care less what the guy did/did not do, I couldn't care less who draws an elk tag........I don't know the guy, nor care to own him........

Bottom line is, hunting elk in PA is nothing like hunting true blue wild elk, and never will be.......
_________________________
"Most people miss opportunity because it comes dressed in overalls, and looks like hard work"

Top
#3127721 - Wed Sep 25 2013 11:00 PM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: Buckshot1822]
deucebump Offline
veteran

Registered: Sun Apr 11 2004
Posts: 1238
Loc: Corry, Pa
Bottom line is, hunting elk in PA is nothing like hunting true blue wild elk, and never will be.......


I have been following this since the very first post and have not posted a thing yet. The above comment is the best sentence I have read yet!

And just to put my opinion out there.... I don't believe a guy that has paid his debt to society should never be allowed to hunt again, BUT I do believe they should not be allowed to purchase any Goverors tags anywhere. They undoubtably, like it or not, become the face of said states Elk hunt. Just as this guy now is the face of PA elk hunting. Black eye for the sportsman of this state. The ONLY reason he buys Gov tags to kill monster elk is to have his name in whatever books he can get them in. It IS NOT for the big antlers. He could easily spend the same money or less and shoot a MUCH bigger bull on a high fence hunt if he simply wanted big antlers, and he is obviously not concerned about being a sportsman or "fair chase" hunting. It's simply an ego boost to him to have his name in a book.
_________________________
There is no "Catch and Release" in the world of hunting!!!!

Mossy Oak Pro Staff
Zink Calls Pro Staff

Top
#3127864 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:30 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: Buckshot1822]
Andy Purnell Offline
veteran

Registered: Tue Mar 04 2003
Posts: 1460
Loc: Pine Glen PA
Originally Posted By: Buckshot1822
What I have learned from this thread......

1. People are jealous because this guy has enough money to spend 40k on a tag

2. Most of these people are upset simply because they have never drawn a tag, and someone well to do can just buy one....

3. People seriously over estimate the sport of hunting Elk in PA



The thing that gets me is this: There are worse "poachers" in pretty much every town in Pa, than this guy, and people aren't all up in arms (at least not to this effect) about those guys out hunting deer, etc..........

I don't care what anyone tells you, most of these elk are pretty tame, there are some exceptions, but most of them are relatively tame, and aren't really afraid of people.......I spend more time in the elk range, and around the elk than probably 95% of the people on here.........

This thread is just full of people who are really upset that, this guy can go and buy a tag for 40k, when they have been applying for 10+ years or whatever it is..........most of the people are using the "poaching" thing as a farce to attack the guy.........

PS......I couldn't care less what the guy did/did not do, I couldn't care less who draws an elk tag........I don't know the guy, nor care to own him........

Bottom line is, hunting elk in PA is nothing like hunting true blue wild elk, and never will be.......



clever
_________________________
DeadRiver AKC Beagles
home 2G
camp 4D

Top
#3127873 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:40 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
blitzinstripes Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Fri Jun 04 2010
Posts: 2992
Loc: SC PA
Well, what is right and ethical isn't always what is legal or illegal. This situation stinks. It has nothing to do with the money. It's that such a great trophy and moment that should have been a celebration for the entire state hunting community, the crowning of a new state record and a world class animal will forever be tainted. If this guy has a shred of dignity at this point, I hope that he will either donate the head to the PGC and keep his name removed from it in public display, or keep it private and never attempt to have it certified as the state record or entered in any book. He has to have heard the news by now that he has recently surpassed Gary Alt as most popular man in PA. If he has any respect for the hunting community, don't submit this for our record.

Top
#3127881 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:49 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
dce Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Mon Aug 20 2001
Posts: 16577
Loc: dubois
I read all that before but still can't find specifically what he did.

Top
#3127882 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:49 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: Buckshot1822]
camohunter7 Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Mon Sep 19 2011
Posts: 682
Loc: Armstrong /Cameron counties,Pa
Originally Posted By: Buckshot1822
What I have learned from this thread......

1. People are jealous because this guy has enough money to spend 40k on a tag

2. Most of these people are upset simply because they have never drawn a tag, and someone well to do can just buy one....

3. People seriously over estimate the sport of hunting Elk in PA



The thing that gets me is this: There are worse "poachers" in pretty much every town in Pa, than this guy, and people aren't all up in arms (at least not to this effect) about those guys out hunting deer, etc..........

I don't care what anyone tells you, most of these elk are pretty tame, there are some exceptions, but most of them are relatively tame, and aren't really afraid of people.......I spend more time in the elk range, and around the elk than probably 95% of the people on here.........

This thread is just full of people who are really upset that, this guy can go and buy a tag for 40k, when they have been applying for 10+ years or whatever it is..........most of the people are using the "poaching" thing as a farce to attack the guy.........

PS......I couldn't care less what the guy did/did not do, I couldn't care less who draws an elk tag........I don't know the guy, nor care to own him........

Bottom line is, hunting elk in PA is nothing like hunting true blue wild elk, and never will be.......

I think the majority of the stink from the whole situation is from an ethical hunting position.
No technically he did nothing illegal here in pa.
It's more of a fact that a person with his history is now a big ugly eye sore for the state . (Notice how the PGC has not published anything on this )
From the time you fist start to hunt , you are taught about ethics , to do the right thing , how to respect the game you chase .
Poaching is one of the most egregious acts to be done in the hunting community,for a convicted poacher to have his fingerprints all over one of the crown jewels of this state ,just stinks .
_________________________
Carve your successes in stone ,
Leave your failures in the sand.

Top
#3127892 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:56 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
blitzinstripes Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Fri Jun 04 2010
Posts: 2992
Loc: SC PA
And anyone who hunts by the rules and teaches young hunters the same, should take this insult personally.

Top
#3127894 - Thu Sep 26 2013 08:58 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
dce Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Mon Aug 20 2001
Posts: 16577
Loc: dubois
I still can't find anything specific on what he did regarding the airplane.It appears most of the charges went to the guide and he got pinched for lying on his behalf.I'm not defending him because obviously he did something.I just haven't found anything that points to him as a blatent poacher.

Top
#3127904 - Thu Sep 26 2013 09:06 AM Re: OkNew state record typical elk? [Re: jakesroost]
dce Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Mon Aug 20 2001
Posts: 16577
Loc: dubois
Bottom line is, hunting elk in PA is nothing like hunting true blue wild elk, and never will be.......

I've hunted elk out west and I live near the Pa herd.There's places out west where elk routinnly graze in people's yards just like they do in Bennezette.However,we have some very wild,remote terrain in the elk country where the elk are far from tame and would be challenging to hunt.A high percentage of elk out west are sniped as they come out into a meadow just like they are in Pa.

My kids and I camped with our horses just outside of Bennezette the second weekend of Sept.We rode 20-30 miles a day for 2 days and only saw one elk and he bailed as soon as he saw us.There was sign and tracks all over the place but the elk didn't show themselves.Of course we were on the other side of the river.It depends on what unit you draw as to whether a Pa elk hunt will be a slam dunk.I have elk within a couple miles of my house.You see them come out into the fields but I've never actually seen one in the woods and I SPEND A LOT OF TIME IN THE WOODS WHERE THEY'RE AT.

Top
Page 25 of 40 < 1 2 ... 23 24 25 26 27 ... 39 40 >


Moderator:  casey, Realtrehntr, treestand91 
Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
Boondock Outdoors
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
54 registered (abowhntr4life, Bearclaw, 11bdickey, basdjs, BCozhunter, 8 invisible), 365 Guests and 12 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
backwoods z, Jwright, mike33554, paraguy, Tiadauton
33791 Registered Users
Recent Posts
Shooting Small Deer
by John1985
3 minutes 11 seconds ago
My boy checking traps with me!!
by stroker97
13 minutes 37 seconds ago
Game Commission Response Question ?
by BushkillPA
15 minutes 51 seconds ago
Chainsaw?
by Clinton County
44 minutes 19 seconds ago
Lower Allegheny
by Serb Paul
51 minutes 54 seconds ago
Here are the sausage and burger recipes we use
by YankeeHunter
Today at 03:23 AM
what powder brand?
by Curly Maple
Today at 03:01 AM
New Topics
Lower Allegheny
by Serb Paul
Looking for Avery deluxe decoy bags...
by lwrsusq
12:39 AM
Patsy Cline
by atr
12:15 AM
Joe Diffie
by DIYASUB
11:46 PM
something different
by TurkeyMike
10:40 PM
Professional Habitat Design
by Flint Lock
10:36 PM
Pine trees from cones
by Sally's Boy
10:26 PM
Top Posters
great white hunter 35834
RonM 31353
RB-HPA 28081
Bluetick 24094
DennyF 22996
TATERDAVID 22764
SigPro2340 21480
Peppy 20895
DIYASUB 20793
timberdoodle 19541
Forum Stats
33791 Members
97 Forums
115266 Topics
1459855 Posts

Max Online: 2060 @ Mon Dec 01 2014 08:50 PM