Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community



Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 >
Topic Options
#2982315 - Tue Mar 05 2013 06:54 PM What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!!
gibsonlespaul Offline
member

Registered: Sun Jan 06 2013
Posts: 174
Loc: pa, pittsburgh, usa
Looking around on other sites i see this to be a huge debate about the best coon trap , in your opinion what is your favorite and why ?

I like the 1 1/2 coil and bought some used DUKES 1 1/2 coil with Double Jaws and find this to be one of the best coon traps in My Opinion !!!! I also replaced all my springs with 1 1/2 Music Wire and they are strong and ready for next season !!!

Top
#2982318 - Tue Mar 05 2013 06:56 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
gibsonlespaul Offline
member

Registered: Sun Jan 06 2013
Posts: 174
Loc: pa, pittsburgh, usa
Also read on Sullivans site that alot of guys over there think the # 2 Double Long Spring is a poor coon trap and i totally DISAGREE with this statement , i love this as a coon trap and it works great !!!

Top
#2982327 - Tue Mar 05 2013 07:05 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Lackawanna Fox Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Mon Feb 04 2008
Posts: 4274
Loc: Scranton PA
ummmmm duke DP

Top
#2982366 - Tue Mar 05 2013 07:49 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
bigogre Offline
member

Registered: Sun Dec 05 2010
Posts: 144
Loc: pa
Z trap work great for me

Top
#2982367 - Tue Mar 05 2013 07:51 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Callmaker60 Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Sun Feb 17 2008
Posts: 3114
Loc: camp hill, Pa.
Z trap work great for me.


Edited by Callmaker60 (Tue Mar 05 2013 07:52 PM)
_________________________
Matthew 22:37-40

Top
#2982444 - Tue Mar 05 2013 08:50 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: Callmaker60]
mauser06 Offline

The man

Registered: Tue Nov 05 2002
Posts: 11846
Loc: PA
#220 at a good bucket set

Top
#2982464 - Tue Mar 05 2013 08:59 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: mauser06]
skube Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Sun Dec 14 2008
Posts: 2074
Loc: perry co.
Originally Posted By: mauser06
#220 at a good bucket set


lol lol
_________________________
NOTE TO VEGETARIANS: My food poops on your food! Enjoy your salad!!!

Top
#2982703 - Wed Mar 06 2013 12:18 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: skube]
dog duster Offline
journeyman

Registered: Wed Feb 03 2010
Posts: 57
Loc: bedford pa.
Dp, your choice what kind.

Top
#2982859 - Wed Mar 06 2013 06:46 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
gibsonlespaul Offline
member

Registered: Sun Jan 06 2013
Posts: 174
Loc: pa, pittsburgh, usa
I should of said excluding dog proofs , what are the other traps you run on your line for coon , Mauser06 i also like a bucket but with a 160 in it !!

Top
#2982960 - Wed Mar 06 2013 11:09 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
dave3 Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Sat May 08 2010
Posts: 451
Loc: Washington Co. , Pa.
I like # 11's , always had too many loses in 1 1/2 coils

Top
#2982981 - Wed Mar 06 2013 11:29 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
longear Offline
old hand

Registered: Tue Mar 03 2009
Posts: 1185
Loc: Oakdale,Pa
after d/ps #1 coils
_________________________
Life Member PA Trappers
NRA Life Member
NTA Life Member

Top
#2983052 - Wed Mar 06 2013 01:01 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Adam Offline

Mod / HPA NW Rep
The man

Registered: Tue Mar 26 2002
Posts: 8678
Loc: Erie, PA
It's all based on opinion. There is no cut and dry "best" trap. For anything.
_________________________
"I suppose it is the way of hunters. We are very odd fellows." ~ Peter Hathaway Capstick

Top
#2983076 - Wed Mar 06 2013 01:20 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: Adam]
mauser06 Offline

The man

Registered: Tue Nov 05 2002
Posts: 11846
Loc: PA
Ive caught more coon in live traps than anything else

Top
#2983078 - Wed Mar 06 2013 01:21 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Callmaker60 Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Sun Feb 17 2008
Posts: 3114
Loc: camp hill, Pa.
It's all based on opinion. There is no cut and dry "best" trap. For anything...Amen.
_________________________
Matthew 22:37-40

Top
#2983163 - Wed Mar 06 2013 03:02 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
cooncrazy Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Tue Jun 25 2002
Posts: 2145
Loc: venango co,pa
usually its a good pocket set for mink or a nice dirthole for fox hase the best coon in it! the trap is secondary!
_________________________
life member pa trappers
distric 1,venango co leader
life member vfw
member fta
member nta

Top
#2983191 - Wed Mar 06 2013 03:21 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: mauser06]
backstrapgihad38 Offline
On the board

Registered: Fri Jul 23 2010
Posts: 235
Loc: southern md/ central pa
Originally Posted By: mauser06
#220 at a good bucket set


tired that aint legal is it ? from what i understood you cant set conibears unless there halfway underwater???

but i use duke 1 1/2 coil spring and some duke 1 1/2 longspring mostly for coon never had any problems with dukes
_________________________
there will be blood pro staff

protecting the sky from things that fly

Top
#2983223 - Wed Mar 06 2013 04:03 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: backstrapgihad38]
walkercoonhunter Offline
old hand

Registered: Mon Mar 14 2005
Posts: 735
Loc: central pa
im greedy but i would like to see us be able to have as many choices as possible for catching coons...snares,coni's,DP's,footholds,etc.....and yes i would use all these methods if they were available....

Top
#2983390 - Wed Mar 06 2013 06:56 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: backstrapgihad38]
mauser06 Offline

The man

Registered: Tue Nov 05 2002
Posts: 11846
Loc: PA
220s are illegal to use in PA on land...160s are allowed in special bucket sets...read your rule book under "artifical cubby" i think it is...

Top
#2983484 - Wed Mar 06 2013 08:47 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
FEEB Offline
On the board

Registered: Sat Dec 01 2012
Posts: 212
Loc: Kittanning
Of the near 3,000 coon i've put up over the past 3 years 90% have been caught in grizz style dp's the other 10% stumbled into k9 sets. So roughly 2,700 coon over three years running a 1% loss in a trap that can be baited and set at home. Can be placed on location in seconds with cable. When set properly is absolutly weather proof. When done right can be checked at 60mph going down the road. And is the most specie specific trap ever built. Barring the fact you like being nipple deep in mud and water digging a pocket or lugging around coni boxes you spent all summer building. Why on God's green earth would you set any other kind of trap for coon?
_________________________
"Little minds are tamed & subdued by misfortune, but great minds rise above them"
Febinger Archery

Top
#2983615 - Wed Mar 06 2013 11:01 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: FEEB]
TrapperShrek Offline
journeyman

Registered: Sat Aug 01 2009
Posts: 91
Loc: SW PA
Originally Posted By: FEEB
Of the near 3,000 coon i've put up over the past 3 years 90% have been caught in grizz style dp's the other 10% stumbled into k9 sets. So roughly 2,700 coon over three years running a 1% loss in a trap that can be baited and set at home. Can be placed on location in seconds with cable. When set properly is absolutly weather proof. When done right can be checked at 60mph going down the road. And is the most specie specific trap ever built. Barring the fact you like being nipple deep in mud and water digging a pocket or lugging around coni boxes you spent all summer building. Why on God's green earth would you set any other kind of trap for coon?


That is the SINGLE best reply I've ever seen. I'll second that.
_________________________
2013-2014 Season

Red fox:7
Grey fox:1
Coyote:1
Coon:25
Possum:1
Muskrat:3

Top
#2983627 - Wed Mar 06 2013 11:10 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: FEEB]
skube Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Sun Dec 14 2008
Posts: 2074
Loc: perry co.
Originally Posted By: FEEB
Of the near 3,000 coon i've put up over the past 3 years 90% have been caught in grizz style dp's the other 10% stumbled into k9 sets. So roughly 2,700 coon over three years running a 1% loss in a trap that can be baited and set at home. Can be placed on location in seconds with cable. When set properly is absolutly weather proof. When done right can be checked at 60mph going down the road. And is the most specie specific trap ever built. Barring the fact you like being nipple deep in mud and water digging a pocket or lugging around coni boxes you spent all summer building. Why on God's green earth would you set any other kind of trap for coon?


3000 in 3 years, got any pics ?
_________________________
NOTE TO VEGETARIANS: My food poops on your food! Enjoy your salad!!!

Top
#2983669 - Wed Mar 06 2013 11:45 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: skube]
dietsch Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Tue Jan 12 2010
Posts: 2734
Loc: north east
Originally Posted By: skube
Originally Posted By: FEEB
Of the near 3,000 coon i've put up over the past 3 years 90% have been caught in grizz style dp's the other 10% stumbled into k9 sets. So roughly 2,700 coon over three years running a 1% loss in a trap that can be baited and set at home. Can be placed on location in seconds with cable. When set properly is absolutly weather proof. When done right can be checked at 60mph going down the road. And is the most specie specific trap ever built. Barring the fact you like being nipple deep in mud and water digging a pocket or lugging around coni boxes you spent all summer building. Why on God's green earth would you set any other kind of trap for coon?


3000 in 3 years, got any pics ?
pics would be good .

Top
#2983694 - Thu Mar 07 2013 12:10 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Forestman3 Offline
veteran

Registered: Fri Feb 09 2007
Posts: 1233
Loc: Huntingdon Pa.
rotfl popcorn

Top
#2983810 - Thu Mar 07 2013 07:51 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
FEEB Offline
On the board

Registered: Sat Dec 01 2012
Posts: 212
Loc: Kittanning
Never said I caught them all. I get between 100/200 a year. I flesh for a couple guys. One of them catches more coon on a good day than most guys catch a year. Wasn't trying to pump myself up. Was trying to prove a point. The numbers are real. No I don't have any pics of the piles of coon I fleshed for other guys. Say what you will, don't really care if you believe me or not.
_________________________
"Little minds are tamed & subdued by misfortune, but great minds rise above them"
Febinger Archery

Top
#2984038 - Thu Mar 07 2013 01:44 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
mauser06 Offline

The man

Registered: Tue Nov 05 2002
Posts: 11846
Loc: PA
I dont think 1000 coon in a season in PA is far fetched at all...youd need to run a long line and have lots of permission...but with our milder winters now, i see no reason why it couldnt be done here in western PA...

Id never dream over 1000 red fox would be possible just looking at areas i have trapped/hunted...but it is..year after year...

Top
#2984043 - Thu Mar 07 2013 01:45 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
longear Offline
old hand

Registered: Tue Mar 03 2009
Posts: 1185
Loc: Oakdale,Pa
1000 coons are possible.
_________________________
Life Member PA Trappers
NRA Life Member
NTA Life Member

Top
#2984057 - Thu Mar 07 2013 02:04 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: FEEB]
skube Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Sun Dec 14 2008
Posts: 2074
Loc: perry co.
Originally Posted By: FEEB
Never said I caught them all. I get between 100/200 a year. I flesh for a couple guys. One of them catches more coon on a good day than most guys catch a year. Wasn't trying to pump myself up. Was trying to prove a point. The numbers are real. No I don't have any pics of the piles of coon I fleshed for other guys. Say what you will, don't really care if you believe me or not.

Easy FEEB,
No one ever said they didn't beleive you. I just never saw that many coon in a pile. Lighten up some.
_________________________
NOTE TO VEGETARIANS: My food poops on your food! Enjoy your salad!!!

Top
#2984950 - Fri Mar 08 2013 12:59 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
gibsonlespaul Offline
member

Registered: Sun Jan 06 2013
Posts: 174
Loc: pa, pittsburgh, usa
Dave3 how exactly did you have alot of losses in your 1 1/2 coils ?

Top
#2985406 - Fri Mar 08 2013 11:23 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
dave3 Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Sat May 08 2010
Posts: 451
Loc: Washington Co. , Pa.
I can't tell you why there were loses, only that it happened more than I liked. It's not because 1 1/2 coils are not strong enough to hold coons, but I've always kept pretty good notes on things, and there were weeks when it would be 10%. Not talking about snapped traps, I would only mark it as a lost animal if there was a disturbance (catch circle) of some kind. I switched to using all Sleepy Creek 11's in 1993 and since then I've had 4 lost coons out of what I would guess were 3 or 4 thousand held in those 20 seasons. I think if you can get a foot centered in an 11, no matter what time I check, it'll be there.

One theory I have on the coils, is that coons fight the trap and may get their back feet on the levers while pulling up on the front foot, releasing themselves ???

Top
#2985617 - Sat Mar 09 2013 10:47 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: dave3]
eagerbeaver Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Mon Jan 09 2006
Posts: 570
Loc: cumberland co., pa
Dave3, you hit the nail on the head.

Top
#2986068 - Sat Mar 09 2013 10:06 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
gibsonlespaul Offline
member

Registered: Sun Jan 06 2013
Posts: 174
Loc: pa, pittsburgh, usa
I do in fact believe there is a best coon trap out there , and it is my belief that the Duke 1 1/2 coil Double jaw is probably the best coon trap out there right now

That being said i also think that the dog proofs are also a good choice , followed by 160's in a bucket ..

This is my opinion and ive used quite alot of diffenent traps over the years...

I used to like the # 1 coil but the catch area is to small for my liking ...

Oh i almost forgot about the # 2 double long spring love this trap for coon also ..

Top
#2986302 - Sun Mar 10 2013 01:53 AM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Rain Man Offline
On the board

Registered: Sat Nov 12 2005
Posts: 339
Loc: Northampton
Originally Posted By: gibsonlespaul
I do in fact believe there is a best coon trap out there , and it is my belief that the Duke 1 1/2 coil Double jaw is probably the best coon trap out there right now


lol, you just made a topic about getting new Duke 1 1/2 double jaws for the first time, and that you can't wait to catch coons in them. You proclaim it as the best coon trap without ever even catching one raccoon in them.

That right there is some priceless internet information grin

Top
#2986832 - Sun Mar 10 2013 11:18 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: gibsonlespaul]
Jayden41 Offline
veteran

Registered: Mon Jul 30 2007
Posts: 1403
Loc: PA
What would make your double jaw that much better then a regular 1 1/2???I run most 1 1/2 for coons and put them all on drags which have cut my losses alot.Decided to buy some DP's for this season to try out.But, i still can't see how a double jaw is that much better of a trap.I guess if you stake your coon sets solid that extra jaw surface would help but they are no stronger.I know you can't be worried about chew outs and have a #2 longspring listed as a favorite trap of yours.I'm with Walker and think snares should be permitted
_________________________
yote addiction: a pack a day

Top
#2987163 - Mon Mar 11 2013 01:20 PM Re: What is the best coon trap ????!!!!!! [Re: Rain Man]
Adam Offline

Mod / HPA NW Rep
The man

Registered: Tue Mar 26 2002
Posts: 8678
Loc: Erie, PA
Originally Posted By: Rain Man
Originally Posted By: gibsonlespaul
I do in fact believe there is a best coon trap out there , and it is my belief that the Duke 1 1/2 coil Double jaw is probably the best coon trap out there right now


lol, you just made a topic about getting new Duke 1 1/2 double jaws for the first time, and that you can't wait to catch coons in them. You proclaim it as the best coon trap without ever even catching one raccoon in them.

That right there is some priceless internet information grin


Exactly.

Anyways...lots of people have their own OPINION as to what the best trap is. However, you are not going to get EVERYONE to agree on 1 particular trap for an animal.
_________________________
"I suppose it is the way of hunters. We are very odd fellows." ~ Peter Hathaway Capstick

Top
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 >


Moderator:  Adam, mauser06, Moss, trapperrick 
Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
26 registered (BCozhunter, artsmag10, flyway, Chaos USMC, btheuret, 4 invisible), 221 Guests and 16 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
tree hugger, Toastedbeercake, WRC, Bishop89, Tky1187
35195 Registered Users
Recent Posts
What's the deal with reloading 7.62x39???
by pymi
03:19 AM
The end to my snake season!
by HD1969
03:10 AM
Emergency foods
by Sneakypete3099
02:56 AM
rare black fawn
by bohunr
02:47 AM
A better way?
by Dobsonknob
02:20 AM
How many elk points
by Dobsonknob
02:12 AM
Berks county buck update 7/22
by Stuffer
02:02 AM
New Topics
A better way?
by Dobsonknob
02:20 AM
What's the deal with reloading 7.62x39???
by Sneakypete3099
02:14 AM
rare black fawn
by gobble561
01:44 AM
The end to my snake season!
by 6.5-284BMF
12:50 AM
Bull Basin Outfitters
by splashindash
12:43 AM
Bushnell night watch IR night vision monocular
by Unk58
11:58 PM
Huge Family Closet Cleanout - camo, ladder stand
by DrewMc
11:24 PM
Top Posters
RonM 39555
great white hunter 37537
RB-HPA 28446
dc 21 26194
Bluetick 24660
DennyF 23629
TATERDAVID 23386
Bearclaw 22980
DIYASUB 22646
timberdoodle 22238
Forum Stats
35195 Members
101 Forums
139263 Topics
1745976 Posts

Max Online: 2060 @ Mon Dec 01 2014 11:50 PM