Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community

Outfitters and Guides Forum



Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#2557386 - Fri Jan 27 2012 12:37 PM Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine
Outlaw12385 Offline
member

Registered: Wed Oct 20 2010
Posts: 147
Loc: Western, PA
I went on a bear hunt last year with 3 rivers guide service with buddies and wanted to post of my experience. Based on my years of hunting/business experience this is my opinion:

1. They were unable to keep bear consistant on the bait ( I dont think the played the quantity/type right)
2. No cameras on barrels (they said they had used them before season, but we all know bears change habbits)
3. We were promised a private cabin...when we got there we had to sleep in the lodge with everyone else
4. Were advised of a 75% kill rate (I know its hunting), but talking to people that were there before, this was not true in previous years either.
5. We were bait hunting, but the dogs run by the same outfitter were in the same area and ended up in our bait sites, only reason we knew is because we happened to be out riding around.
6.Guide has regular "clients" (Friends) who magically ended up on kill sites.

I will never return. I know they go out to the sports show, so I just wanted to get this info out on the web for people searching their name.

Top
#2557391 - Fri Jan 27 2012 12:41 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
lastchance54 Offline
member

Registered: Sat Sep 03 2011
Posts: 161
Loc: Central, PA
.


Edited by RB-HPA (Fri Jan 27 2012 01:03 PM)
Edit Reason: No relevence to the post

Top
#2557609 - Fri Jan 27 2012 03:43 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Andy Purnell Offline
veteran

Registered: Tue Mar 04 2003
Posts: 1462
Loc: Pine Glen PA
I stay with those guys to hunt hare in March, this will be our 4th year. They have never steered us wrong.
_________________________
DeadRiver AKC Beagles
home 2G
camp 4D

Top
#2557663 - Fri Jan 27 2012 04:20 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Outlaw12385 Offline
member

Registered: Wed Oct 20 2010
Posts: 147
Loc: Western, PA
Well sir I don't argue they are nice people. However there is a huge difference between rabbits and bear. Plus when you are there he isn't running multiple clients for big game. His hound hunting bears conflicts with over bait. You don't put a guy on a bear bait site that you had a pack of dogs battle in the same week... If anyone wants to know the truth of what they do and why it's wrong they can PM me. Speaking of which I forgot to mention he promised three of us that we could dog hunt for the same price but that also changed when we showed up. I'm not one bitter person three ppl can confirm this And I know the other guys in camp all had the same stories of lies. It's taken six months of reflection before I posted, I have had a lot of time to make these conclusions. They may be the worlds best rabbit lodge but lack quality for bear.

Top
#2559819 - Sun Jan 29 2012 02:37 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Bob T. Offline
apprentice

Registered: Sun Jan 29 2012
Posts: 18
Loc: Chester Co., PA
I have hunted in Maine for bear the last two years and plan on going back again this year. I do not know of this particular outfitter, but I am familiar with Maine hunting laws. Hunting over bait and hunting with dogs are two seperate seasons and do not overlap! If you are looking for a great bear hunt in Maine over bait or with dogs, Oxbow Lodge rocks! Chad and the gang have their stuff together and make you feel like you are at home.

Top
#2560019 - Sun Jan 29 2012 05:12 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Outlaw12385 Offline
member

Registered: Wed Oct 20 2010
Posts: 147
Loc: Western, PA
The third week overlaps for bait, which is the first week to run dogs. I will never go back to maine to hunt bear over buckets (just found I didn't enjoy it) buck regardless of the outfitter I wouldn't go in an overlap if they offer both. You don't know where or how far dogs run bear and I think it generally screw the baits for bait hunts. Then again these clowns were surprised a bear they jumped less than a mile from our bait sites ran through them.... So they lacked professional judgement as well.

Top
#2560242 - Sun Jan 29 2012 07:15 PM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Outlaw12385 Offline
member

Registered: Wed Oct 20 2010
Posts: 147
Loc: Western, PA
@Bob...from Maine's website..yese there is overlap:

•Hunting with Bait - August 27, 2012 through September 22, 2012 (Bait can be placed beginning July 28, 2012)
•Hunting with Dogs - September 10, 2012 through October 26, 2012

Top
#2565179 - Thu Feb 02 2012 04:11 AM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Big Ken Offline
Honored

Registered: Fri Mar 11 2005
Posts: 7692
Loc: Pitman
Some folks like bait hunts for bear...Not me...The spot & stalk hunt in BC featured all day action and we did see bears all day.Over 40 in a week and you could take your pick as to color and size,,very exciting and complete....I'd gladly save up and do this type of hunt over a Maine hunt where you would be more likely to shoot any legal bear as long as you saw one.
_________________________

Top
#2565180 - Thu Feb 02 2012 04:13 AM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Big Ken Offline
Honored

Registered: Fri Mar 11 2005
Posts: 7692
Loc: Pitman
A word to the wise..At the Outdoor show, an outfitter will tell you what you want to hear so keep that in mind!
_________________________

Top
#2565184 - Thu Feb 02 2012 04:48 AM Re: Caution on 3 Rivers Guide Service - Crystal Maine [Re: Outlaw12385]
Fly Guy Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Fri Jul 07 2006
Posts: 3722
Loc: Up A Creek - No Paddle
Gotta agree with Big Ken on this, for the most part. There are good, bad and ugly outfitters out there. Unfortunately, my experience is that they will tell you what ever you want to hear just to get you to book. Nowadays, I do more research then talking. Statistics don't lie but liars use statistics.
_________________________
There is no such thing as a stupid question, just stupid people asking questions.

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


Moderator:  gentleben, HuntingPA 
Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
146 registered (410-er, 44 hunt club, 284, 1MoreGun, 25ftup, 143 Coyote ln, 14 invisible), 418 Guests and 14 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
Smike42089, bdub33, ScoobyDoo, Shotgun92, Enigma
34394 Registered Users
Recent Posts
MB 550's
by WPAtrapper
0 seconds ago
MB 550's
by WPAtrapper
1 minute 58 seconds ago
Spinoff of Last Letter Game
by RonM
3 minutes 21 seconds ago
POTD 7/31/2015
by RonM
5 minutes 28 seconds ago
spam email from HPA?
by Birch812
7 minutes 46 seconds ago
Random sentence game
by RonM
10 minutes 8 seconds ago
The last letter game
by RonM
15 minutes 40 seconds ago
New Topics
Light height on Boat?
by Sawedoff
Unsold 1st round
by BlackSwattie
Ruger American Compact .243 18" barrel review
by TOP PREDATOR
06:00 PM
Fishing Arthur on Regatta Weekend - A good Launch?
by Nak
04:43 PM
Utility Trailer
by Karl Power
03:56 PM
Snow goose hunting
by Longneckin'
01:58 PM
From the Stream
by grousedog20
11:28 AM
Top Posters
great white hunter 36587
RonM 34680
RB-HPA 28321
Bluetick 24545
DennyF 23290
TATERDAVID 22976
DIYASUB 21630
SigPro2340 21525
Peppy 20921
dc 21 20783
Forum Stats
34394 Members
99 Forums
124980 Topics
1573952 Posts

Max Online: 2060 @ Mon Dec 01 2014 08:50 PM