Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community



Page 2 of 2 < 1 2
Topic Options
#2408455 - Sat Oct 22 2011 08:25 PM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: great white hunter]
mountainhippie Offline
The man

Registered: Tue Nov 28 2006
Posts: 9031
Loc: Newark, DE
I read in a Capstick book about a Cape Buffalo being brought down with a .22 hornet. I think it was The Last Ivory Hunter.
_________________________
Go n-ithe an cat thú is go n-ithe an diabhal an cat!

Top
#2408486 - Sat Oct 22 2011 08:48 PM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: great white hunter]
JGR Offline
veteran

Registered: Sun Aug 15 2010
Posts: 1203
Loc: PA
There is no minimum caliber you can use in PA. There is for muzzle-loader, and archery. But I could legally take my .17 HMR bolt action or .22 revolver, But not my Desert Eagle .50 cal, my ranch 30, or my 12 gauge 1100?!?
And for the extra money, if I can even get the doe tag.
I get 1 week to shoot a doe, not a buck, with my muzzle-loader. I'll save the couple dollars and carry my bow.

Sometimes this commenwealth is dumb.
_________________________
JR

Top
#2408606 - Sat Oct 22 2011 10:50 PM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: JGR]
mossie Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Sun Dec 19 2004
Posts: 1940
Loc: PA
As long as it's centerfire caliber doesn't matter in the firearms season.

I personally saw a doe taken at around 100 yards with one shot cleanly dropping it where it stood by a .222 rifle. I remember thinking that I felt bad that he didn't have a more suitable rifle for deer hunting when we left the camp that morning. He took deer with it every year and never felt undergunned. This was at least 35 years ago but I still remember it very vividly to this day. My friend that shot it passed away last year.

Top
#2409033 - Sun Oct 23 2011 03:54 AM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: JGR]
brute750 Offline
On the board

Registered: Fri Mar 18 2011
Posts: 239
Loc: Lackawanna County, 3D
 Originally Posted By: JGR
And for the extra money, if I can even get the doe tag.
I get 1 week to shoot a doe, not a buck, with my muzzle-loader. I'll save the couple dollars and carry my bow.

Sometimes this commenwealth is dumb.


If you were using a flintlock, you would get an extra 4 weeks to shoot a doe, or maybe even 2 doe if you don't get a buck.

Top
#2409183 - Sun Oct 23 2011 11:26 AM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: JGR]
Tony300wby Online   content
old hand

Registered: Tue Nov 30 2010
Posts: 1176
Loc: Pa. Lehigh
 Originally Posted By: JGR
There is no minimum caliber you can use in PA. There is for muzzle-loader, and archery. But I could legally take my .17 HMR bolt action or .22 revolver, But not my Desert Eagle .50 cal, my ranch 30, or my 12 gauge 1100?!?
And for the extra money, if I can even get the doe tag.
I get 1 week to shoot a doe, not a buck, with my muzzle-loader. I'll save the couple dollars and carry my bow.

Sometimes this commenwealth is dumb.


You can NOT legally hunt deer with your 17HMR or a 22 rimfire.

You claim that the commenwealth is "dumb". Is it "dumb" because you dont agree with the regulations or that you dont understand them?

Good luck, Tony

Top
#2409200 - Sun Oct 23 2011 11:35 AM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: Tony300wby]
treedaddy Offline
old hand

Registered: Thu Feb 05 2009
Posts: 1054
Loc: Indiana co. Penna.
A big bore is poor replacement for good shot placement,
_________________________
"one hand clapping" mork from ork

Top
#2409215 - Sun Oct 23 2011 11:43 AM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: Tony300wby]
great white hunter Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Mon Jan 29 2001
Posts: 37357
Loc: greensburg
 Originally Posted By: Tony300wby
 Originally Posted By: JGR
There is no minimum caliber you can use in PA. There is for muzzle-loader, and archery. But I could legally take my .17 HMR bolt action or .22 revolver, But not my Desert Eagle .50 cal, my ranch 30, or my 12 gauge 1100?!?
And for the extra money, if I can even get the doe tag.
I get 1 week to shoot a doe, not a buck, with my muzzle-loader. I'll save the couple dollars and carry my bow.

Sometimes this commenwealth is dumb.


You can NOT legally hunt deer with your 17HMR or a 22 rimfire.

You claim that the commenwealth is "dumb". Is it "dumb" because you dont agree with the regulations or that you dont understand them?

Good luck, Tony
Yup, Has to be a centerfire!

Top
#2409225 - Sun Oct 23 2011 11:47 AM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: great white hunter]
YankeeHunter Offline
The man

Registered: Fri Jul 27 2007
Posts: 9683
Loc: Wayne Co., Pa
You can kill a deer with a 22LR or 22 Mag (not legally), but should you? I would make sure whatever centerfire round I chose to use would be one I was proficient and accurate with and guarantee a swift merciful kill.
_________________________
Vurt da Furk?

Top
#2409269 - Sun Oct 23 2011 12:07 PM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: JGR]
John S Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Tue Jul 25 2000
Posts: 38864
Loc: Lancaster,PA,Lancaster
Where did you ever get the idea you can legally hunt deer with a .22 or .17 rimfire. After that rant about dumb, you may want to reconsider who you aimed it at.
_________________________
Life is short, Eat dessert first!

Top
#2409939 - Sun Oct 23 2011 09:36 PM Re: Caliber minimum for deer? [Re: John S]
overthehill Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Sun Mar 25 2007
Posts: 485
Loc: beaver county, pennsylvania
every year same debate. yes, .17 remington centerfire, .204 ruger, 22-250, .222, .223 etc. are legal for deer in pa. do they kill deer? yes. are they a good choice for an average hunter? probably not. at the other end of spectrum are those that proclaim a .300 win mag is too light. to each his own. one thing to consider is that most of the .224 diameter bullets are either target or varmint and not suitable for deer size animals.

Top
Page 2 of 2 < 1 2


Moderator:  BCozhunter, corey22, DIYASUB, Samuel 
Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
90 registered (Andrew C., atr, archeryman32, bad primer, 2-State Archer, 11 invisible), 288 Guests and 6 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
Kode, SK149, paduckhunter19, kba, dallasb
35091 Registered Users
Recent Posts
Nitti's part II
by pabuckkiller
prices of used guns
by fortgreg
Recent shots
by Griz
Portable Generator
by Sekora
Do You Think More or Less Gun Control will Save US
by farmerbrown
Joke of the Day 4/30/16
by atr
The last letter game
by dc 21
New Topics
Recent shots
by Griz
Portable Generator
by Sekora
Joke of the Day 4/30/16
by dc 21
April 30, Day 1
by jmbear12
07:32 AM
Trout Magnet
by Windwalker7
12:52 AM
Nirvana
by atr
12:33 AM
SGL # 44 Volunteer Work Day
by R. S. B.
09:30 PM
Top Posters
RonM 38567
great white hunter 37357
RB-HPA 28440
dc 21 25238
Bluetick 24660
DennyF 23526
TATERDAVID 23233
DIYASUB 22459
Bearclaw 22316
timberdoodle 21956
Forum Stats
35091 Members
100 Forums
136580 Topics
1713977 Posts

Max Online: 2060 @ Mon Dec 01 2014 11:50 PM