Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community

Hunting Laws and Regulations Forum



Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Topic Options
#1441226 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:40 PM Food plots vs baiting
rlfb74 Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Mon Nov 01 1999
Posts: 2256
Loc: York, PA
Why aren't food plots considered baiting?
_________________________
You can shear a sheep many times, but you can only skin it once.

Top
#1441239 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:45 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: rlfb74]
47studebaker Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Thu Aug 25 2005
Posts: 1895
Loc: North Central PA 2G
because the LAW says they aren't

Top
#1441244 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:46 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: rlfb74]
Guest Offline
Stopped counting

Registered: Sun Mar 18 2001
Posts: 27829
Loc: Lancaster County
Because they don't bring a critter to a specific spot, like a pile of corn would.

If they were baiting, then the PGC wouldn't be allowed to plant food plots on the SGL's.

Planting an apple tree would/could be considered baiting.
_________________________


"It only takes one person to care in order to get something changed." Bryan S.

Top
#1441260 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:53 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: Guest]
jun1or Offline
Honored

Registered: Sun Dec 21 2008
Posts: 5481
Loc: Q-ville and 5c
I still think its the same concept. I don't care if corn comes off an ear or out of a bag, its still corn. same as whatever else is planted for a plot. its put there to entice the deer to come.
_________________________
"god fearin, hard workin. combine driver"

Top
#1441265 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:54 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: 47studebaker]
rlfb74 Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Mon Nov 01 1999
Posts: 2256
Loc: York, PA
 Originally Posted By: 47studebaker
because the LAW says they aren't


That was a waste of your time writing that response and an even greater waste of my time reading it.
_________________________
You can shear a sheep many times, but you can only skin it once.

Top
#1441271 - Sat Nov 14 2009 08:58 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: Guest]
rlfb74 Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Mon Nov 01 1999
Posts: 2256
Loc: York, PA
 Originally Posted By: Dutch
Because they don't bring a critter to a specific spot, like a pile of corn would.

If they were baiting, then the PGC wouldn't be allowed to plant food plots on the SGL's.

Planting an apple tree would/could be considered baiting.


I didn't really mean the big food plots of a bunch of acres. What I was wondering was this...I was reading an article in a hunting magazine (don't remember which one) that said the author picked out a spot for his stand and then took some Sew and Grow and made a small 10' x 10' food plot near his stand. This helped bring feeding deer into bow range. Just wondering if that was legal in PA or not.
_________________________
You can shear a sheep many times, but you can only skin it once.

Top
#1441289 - Sat Nov 14 2009 09:06 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: rlfb74]
Woodywoodduck Offline
VIP

Registered: Fri Jun 06 2003
Posts: 12262
Loc: 5B wishing to be in 4B
 Originally Posted By: rlfb74
 Originally Posted By: 47studebaker
because the LAW says they aren't


That was a waste of your time writing that response and an even greater waste of my time reading it.


Might have been a Waste of your Time...

But, what 47studebaker Posted was STRAIGHT and to the Point and WHAT is FACT!

Sorry, you feel it was a Waste of your Time, But he was Right on the Mark!!

Place it they will come..... plant it, they will come... 1 Illegal, 1 Legal!

Top
#1441299 - Sat Nov 14 2009 09:15 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: rlfb74]
Woodywoodduck Offline
VIP

Registered: Fri Jun 06 2003
Posts: 12262
Loc: 5B wishing to be in 4B
 Originally Posted By: rlfb74
 Originally Posted By: Dutch
Because they don't bring a critter to a specific spot, like a pile of corn would.

If they were baiting, then the PGC wouldn't be allowed to plant food plots on the SGL's.

Planting an apple tree would/could be considered baiting.


I didn't really mean the big food plots of a bunch of acres. What I was wondering was this...I was reading an article in a hunting magazine (don't remember which one) that said the author picked out a spot for his stand and then took some Sew and Grow and made a small 10' x 10' food plot near his stand. This helped bring feeding deer into bow range. Just wondering if that was legal in PA or not.


- In place of Rolls Eyes!

PERFECTLY Legal!!

Place the SEEDs, the Seeds Germinate, Grow Roots, Push Stems and Leaves up out of the Ground... Stems and Leaves Gather Light, Produce Fruit, seeds, what ever the plant was intended to produce..

PERFECTLY Legal!


Place it they will come (Great Big Ole Pile of Corn, Apples, Pears, Turnip Tops, Peanuts, pop corn and Cracker Jacks)- Illegal!

Plant it they Will Come (seeds, grow into plants and fruit and drop thier fruits or seeds to be eaten by the Critters)- Legal! Don't matter if it is 3 foot Square, 1,000 ACRES Square!



Why can not guys under stand.. Put a SEED in the Ground, Seed Germinates, Pushs up out of the Ground, Grows Stem, Leaves and then Fruit or seed pods and the Critters eat it and it is Perfectly LEGAL?????


Is it that Hard to understand Planting, Seed Germinates and so forth is Perfectly LEGAL and has no matter what size footage, acre or miless it is???


BUT, if you plant those seeds, let them grow, then Harvest the off come of the seeds into a Bucket, Bushel Basket, Sack and Transport it to another place or even 1 foot away onto Piles, it is NOT Legal!


Is it that Hard to understand???

Top
#1441326 - Sat Nov 14 2009 09:30 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: Woodywoodduck]
rlfb74 Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Mon Nov 01 1999
Posts: 2256
Loc: York, PA
 Originally Posted By: Woodywoodduck
 Originally Posted By: rlfb74
 Originally Posted By: 47studebaker
because the LAW says they aren't


That was a waste of your time writing that response and an even greater waste of my time reading it.


Might have been a Waste of your Time...

But, what 47studebaker Posted was STRAIGHT and to the Point and WHAT is FACT!

Sorry, you feel it was a Waste of your Time, But he was Right on the Mark!!

Place it they will come..... plant it, they will come... 1 Illegal, 1 Legal!


It was correct and to the point, but it did not explain why. That is why it was a waste of my time. It didn't accomplish anything. If "because the law says so" were everyones answer to a question in this forum, we wouldn't need the forum. Explain why, not just because it says so.


Edited by rlfb74 (Sat Nov 14 2009 09:52 PM)
_________________________
You can shear a sheep many times, but you can only skin it once.

Top
#1441350 - Sat Nov 14 2009 09:40 PM Re: Food plots vs baiting [Re: Woodywoodduck]
rlfb74 Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: Mon Nov 01 1999
Posts: 2256
Loc: York, PA
 Originally Posted By: Woodywoodduck
Is it that Hard to understand???


Is it that hard to explain without being sarcastic? It was never explained to me and does not explain the difference in the law book (that I could find). If I plant a small food plot and HAVE NO INTENTIONS OF HARVESTING IT, than why is it not baiting? Seeds, germinations, blah, blah, blah. It is no different. The main intention was to lure game.

The land I hunt was logged off 2 years ago. This winter I'm going to go and clear off 6 spots all over the property that now get sunlight. There is no way I can get harvesting equipment into them because of the terrain. I'm going to plant them all with different types of food plots (clover, turnips, etc.) I might even plant a few rows of corn in one or two of them. Then, I'm going to plant 6 or 7 apple trees in each one of them. Then, I'm going to build a treestand at each one and put up trail cameras and take pics of what I see. Finally, I'm going to hunt over them and you're going to tell me that isn't baiting?
_________________________
You can shear a sheep many times, but you can only skin it once.

Top
Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >


Moderator:  BCozhunter, corey22, DIYASUB, Samuel 
Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
Boondock Outdoors
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
126 registered (BCozhunter, Bearclaw, 87notch, benelli21, 257bob, Allen Martin, 11 invisible), 437 Guests and 17 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
redgtc, HeclaSportsman, Helshollowhunter, 8man, trappin14
33677 Registered Users
Recent Posts
Fresh Snow in 5C for Thursday + Friday
by Going_Trad
4 minutes 2 seconds ago
Release Problem
by RayRay
4 minutes 10 seconds ago
Huntingpa/pocono bear gang success
by nabs5
7 minutes 37 seconds ago
Happy Thanksgiving!
by casey
10 minutes 6 seconds ago
hunting in a snowstorm
by duck duck goose
12 minutes 56 seconds ago
Schuylkill county?
by nabs5
14 minutes 15 seconds ago
Remington 141 .35
by quackmaster4
20 minutes 50 seconds ago
New Topics
Release Problem
by Turkeyman
Suggestion for trailcam theft.
by kdvarmint
Shot my first coyote tonight!!!
by grouse11
03:08 AM
Happy Thanksgiving!
by BCozhunter
02:00 AM
Bill Monroe
by atr
12:49 AM
And on this thanksgiving....
by Danesdad
11:46 PM
today was my turn in our group
by ratherbhuntin
11:40 PM
Top Posters
great white hunter 35698
RonM 30963
RB-HPA 27995
Bluetick 24025
DennyF 22988
TATERDAVID 22744
SigPro2340 21480
Peppy 20895
DIYASUB 20675
timberdoodle 19432
Forum Stats
33677 Members
97 Forums
113938 Topics
1442094 Posts

Max Online: 1869 @ Mon Nov 03 2014 08:43 PM