Click here HuntingPA.com
Outdoor Community

Firearm Forum



Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >
Topic Options
#1262797 - Tue Jul 28 2009 07:47 PM 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen
NorthEast Cammer Offline
Honored

Registered: Sat Nov 10 2007
Posts: 5480
Loc: SW PA
another good matchup from the larger calibers. which one would you all like to have in the cabinet??

338 Winchester Mag vs. 35 Whelen

In my opinion, if I were to choose 1 rifle to cover anything I might ever encounter, it very well might be a 338 Win Mag. but the 'ol Whelen is sure attractive \:\)

In this matchup, case capacity and ballistics favor the 338 WM. while the recoil can be a bit much for some. the Whelen is a little easier on the shoulder, The 35 Whelen is going to kick...but not as much as a .338 Mag and not as much as a .300 Win Mag....perhaps as much as the 7mm Mag....but what an upgrade. 2600 for a 250 grain bullet out of an '06 case
338 vs 35 Whelen
Only one choice allowed


Votes accepted starting: Tue Jul 28 2009 07:46 PM
You must vote before you can view the results of this poll.

Top
#1262809 - Tue Jul 28 2009 07:56 PM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: NorthEast Cammer]
Cold Bore Offline
old hand

Registered: Fri Oct 22 1999
Posts: 1073
Loc: PA
I'm not a huge magnum fan, but of the magnums, the 338 WM is about the most sensible to me.

It's a bit stout for PA, but if you hunt something that justifies a magnum, the magnums smaller than the 338 WM are too easily imitated by other "standard" cartridges. When you need enough of a difference to get outside of the 30-06-ish arena, and need to step up to a magnum, you might as well skip the rest and go to the 338.

Besides, if I'm going to stay with the 30-06 parent case, it's going to be (and IS !) a 338-06 for me.

Top
#1263038 - Tue Jul 28 2009 09:59 PM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: Cold Bore]
*Moose Offline
VIP

Registered: Sat Nov 15 2008
Posts: 13401
Loc: hearts in New England
Ahhh moose cartridges. Now yer talkin'. I picked the .35 Whelen cause I want to get one for moose whenever I get drawn again. I shot one with the .30-06 and wasn't impressed and one with the .450 Marlin and lost an insane amount of meat so I'm figuring something halfway in between is exactly what I'm looking for.
_________________________
I hunt Bools n Bux.

Top
#1263292 - Wed Jul 29 2009 03:08 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: *Moose]
mackgee Offline
HPA Sponsor
Honored

Registered: Sun May 31 2009
Posts: 5433
Loc: Jonestown, PA
I went with the Whelen as well. I love big bore guns and I would have to say that for Pennsylvania woods hunting the .35 Whelen is about as good as it gets in my mind. I am planning on hopefully securing a Remington custom shop mountain rifle in this caliber when I get home.

Top
#1263297 - Wed Jul 29 2009 03:30 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: *Moose]
John Henry Online   content
Stopped counting

Registered: Sun Feb 09 2003
Posts: 18960
Loc: Hanover, PA
Buddy shot a Moose in Maine last year with a 35 Whelen Improved.
_________________________
Do your SPORTIN' in WHARTON, Population 92

POTTER COUNTY, GOD's COUNTRY

Top
#1263307 - Wed Jul 29 2009 04:24 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: John Henry]
Smokey in PHX Offline
enthusiast

Registered: Tue May 19 2009
Posts: 681
Loc: Arizona
I have seen several elk shot with the 338 WM and most fell at the shot. All were well placed shots. Elk hunting is all I have used this caliber for so I do find it limited in the lower US. My rifle is heavy but somewhat tames the recoil. If I had to choose between the two I feel the .338 WM is the only way to go.

Top
#1263312 - Wed Jul 29 2009 04:47 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: NorthEast Cammer]
tridaddy Offline
On the board

Registered: Fri Jan 04 2008
Posts: 297
Loc: smethport p.a.
i barreled 98 mauser for 35 whelen when comparing it to 338 win magnum 250 300 fps differance like comparing a 6mm to a 243 win count in the cost of ammo. belted case compared to a resized 30-06 i'll take a whelen any day. and have a chance to really wear out a big bore high power barrel.

Top
#1263330 - Wed Jul 29 2009 06:09 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: NorthEast Cammer]
tridaddy Offline
On the board

Registered: Fri Jan 04 2008
Posts: 297
Loc: smethport p.a.
speculate that the 358 win in a savage 99 was a great elk rifle. the 35 whelen still having a following through out the 50's to present day then remington making it legit in 90 or so. i had a buddy that owned a 700 classic i loaded and shot a lot of stuff through that rifle it was fun. i got the bug my self. i always passed on the 338.

Top
#1263341 - Wed Jul 29 2009 06:39 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: tridaddy]
rflktrman Offline
Carpal \'Tunnel

Registered: Sun Nov 26 2006
Posts: 4106
Loc: Robinson, Indiana county, Pa
I got a .338 because I had a great deal on it. Still have not fired it but since I hunt with a .300 Win believe I will love the big bang. My brother-in-law used to own one and he didn't mind the recoil He is a bit smaller than me instature too by about 50 pounds LOL.

Top
#1263369 - Wed Jul 29 2009 07:29 AM Re: 338 Win Mag vs. 35 Whelen [Re: rflktrman]
angus Online   content
veteran

Registered: Sat Mar 26 2005
Posts: 1478
Loc: Adams county
Ballistics of the .338 are much better but, the lower recoil on the .35 made it my pick. Magnum power from a non belted case, easier to reload, and brass lasts longer. The.35 is all you would need for any North American game. Personally, I would split the difference and go .338-06.
_________________________
If you enjoy hunting please find a way to give back to the sport. Our children will thank you.

Top
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >


Google Ads
HuntingPA Sponsors
60X Custom Strings
ADT Security
Arrowhead
Boondock Outdoors
FoxPro
Growing Up With Guns
Hilltop Seeds
Hunting GPS Maps
Huntworth Gear
James Creek Outfitters
Knob Mountain Kennel
Lancaster Archery
Lowes Whitetail Scents
Martz Gap Hunting Preserve
Midwest Turkey Call Supply
Magees Optics
Mt. Hope Game Preserve
Night Eyes Predator Lights
No Limits Outdoors
On-Point Outfitters
Outdoorsman's Insight Magazine
Pheasants Forever
Premier Hunting Adventures
Randy Kuntz's Taxidermy
Realtree
Stony Gun & Archery
TrailCamPro
Two Bear Outfitters
Ultimate Camo
Who's Online
325 registered (17 furball, 2Bornot2B, 284, 2ballcane, 3D Hunter, 1shot2kills, 27 invisible), 763 Guests and 13 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Google Ads
Newest Members
Dan W York, roughneck065, Tompovo, Bogey, JessJ
33504 Registered Users
Recent Posts
Fur down
by Fox commander
Rumble in Rockaway NJ
by dc 21
Eric Frein Captured?
by TPlank
Day 24, October 31st - Halloween!
by yetihunter1
fall turkey rifle selection
by wincester-only
10-30-2014 13 Point down
by Big-Ben
Opening Day
by great white hunter
New Topics
Apple Tree
by wolfehunter
A shot deer "back tracking". What are the signs?
by Deer archer
Hang On Treestand
by Backwoods
08:57 AM
Joke of the Day 10/31/14
by dc 21
08:55 AM
Should Yotes?
by Clearfield12
08:48 AM
BBD 10-30-14!!!!!
by JasonN
08:31 AM
Past Poll results 2011-2013
by TAMU
08:01 AM
Top Posters
great white hunter 35450
RonM 30452
RB-HPA 27923
Bluetick 23985
DennyF 22933
TATERDAVID 22709
SigPro2340 21480
Peppy 20884
DIYASUB 20534
timberdoodle 19305
Forum Stats
33504 Members
97 Forums
112100 Topics
1417875 Posts

Max Online: 1814 @ Wed Oct 22 2014 09:30 PM